Is a Holy Kiss on the Lips Biblical? Meaning of Romans 16:16

Yes, the Bible instructs Christians to “greet one another with a holy kiss” (Romans 16:16), but this command describes a culturally familiar greeting expressing sincere, familial, and holy affection rather than a romantic or sensual kiss.

The essential biblical meaning is to welcome fellow believers as members of one family in Christ, with genuine love, equality, honor, peace, and mutual respect. In cultures where a kiss is appropriate, Christians may practice the greeting literally; in other cultures, a handshake, hug, warm smile, or heartfelt word can express the same principle.

Where does the Bible mention the holy kiss?

There are several passages in the New Testament that refer to a “holy kiss” (Romans 16:16; 1 Corinthians 16:20; 2 Corinthians 13:12; 1 Thessalonians 5:26). While the apostle Peter does not use the words “holy kiss,” he does command us to “greet one another with the kiss of love” (1 Peter 5:14).

In Romans 16:16, Paul writes, “Greet one another with a holy kiss. All the churches of Christ greet you.” Paul would often close his letters with personal greetings and wisdom. In Romans, he recognizes a long list of people and their ministry to Christ and others.

Paul writes again in 1 Corinthians 16:20: “All the brothers send you greetings. Greet one another with a holy kiss.” Again, the apostle gives a personal note toward the end of his first letter to this immature church, one with a number of spiritual and relational issues.

In his next letter to the same church, Paul commands toward the end of the letter, “Greet one another with a holy kiss.” (1 Corinthians 13:12) Here at the close, he encourages the church to “aim for restoration, comfort one another, agree with another, live in peace.” (2 Corinthians 13:11) His next statement repeats the call to greet brothers and sisters with a holy kiss, a symbol of the restoration and peace.

Finally, in 1 Thessalonians 5:26, Paul simply says, “Greet all the brothers with a holy kiss.” This comes after some practical instructions for Christian living in spiritual community. Paul encourages the local church to encourage the downcast, help the weak, and be patient with each other.

PassageInstructionEmphasis in context
Romans 16:16“Greet one another with a holy kiss”Fellowship among a diverse congregation
1 Corinthians 16:20“Greet one another with a holy kiss”Visible affection and familial love
2 Corinthians 13:12“Greet one another with a holy kiss”Restoration, comfort, agreement, and peace
1 Thessalonians 5:26“Greet all the brothers with a holy kiss”Acceptance and patience within the faith family
1 Peter 5:14“Greet one another with the kiss of love”Love among believers

Since Paul shares this practical instruction four times to three different churches, we can infer it was something he taught to every fellowship. The holy kiss once more symbolizes the acceptance of every member of the faith family.

What does “holy kiss” mean?

When Paul says to greet one another with a “holy kiss,” the Greek phrase is philema hagion. Philema is kiss, modified by the next word, hagion, meaning holy (set apart and sacred). Paul uses this phrase four times, and the apostle Peter uses a similar phrase in 1 Peter 5:14, a “kiss of love,” or philmeati agapes.

In each instance, the kiss is supposed to be loving, holy, and sacred. The adjective holy in Romans 16:16 signifies that this kiss is different from romantic or sensual kisses. Instead, it embodies the love, purity, and sanctity of Christian fellowship: “Set the believers an example in speech, in conduct, in love, in faith, in purity” (1 Timothy 4:12, ESV).

It wasn’t a sexual or romantic kiss. On the contrary, it was meant to be for brothers and sisters in the same family. Paul took a common cultural greeting and expanded it to mean something more spiritual and eternal.

Surely, “the holy kiss” meant, at least, kissing without lust. But again, kissing in the ancient world (and in Scripture) was far more familial than romantic.

How was kissing used in biblical times?

In New Testament times and in the culture of the Near East, a kiss was a common form of greeting among family and close friends. A kiss, then, symbolized love, brotherly affection, and fellowship.

Both the Greco-Roman and Jewish cultures greeted some people with a kiss. In the Roman or Hellenistic culture, a kiss was a common greeting, especially among men of equal status. It communicated friendship and kinship. A kiss on the cheek or forehead meant a certain level of affection, and a kiss on the lips might indicate deeper friendship or love between family members.

Roman society had different kinds of kisses: osculum (friendly), basium (romantic), and suavium (a really passionate kiss). The osculum was for public, social greetings.

Soldiers might greet one another with a kiss after not seeing each other for a while, and political allies might kiss to signify their loyalty. Public osculum kisses could point to social standing. Someone of higher class might grant a kiss to a person of lower status, but the reverse only happened with permission.

Greeting with a kiss also had meaning in the Jewish culture, even with a biblical background. A kiss on the forehead or beard was a respectful act toward elders or teachers, and this made Judas’ kiss such a deep and hurtful betrayal of Jesus (Luke 22:47).

The Jewish culture had strong boundaries on physical affection, however. Kisses were reserved for family or very close companions, not given lightly by any means. And it would almost never happen between a Jew and a Gentile, who were considered unclean.

Examples of affectionate and respectful kisses in Scripture

Paul and Peter called upon biblical background for such a kiss. Jacob and Esau kissed in a moment of reconciliation (Genesis 34:4). Joseph kissed his brothers when he forgave them (Genesis 45:15). Samuel kissed Saul when anointing him as king (1 Samuel 10:1). David and Jonathan had such a close relationship, closer than brothers, expressed with a kiss (1 Samuel 20:41).

We can see numerous examples of this sort of kiss in the Bible:

  • Jacob kissed his father (Genesis 27:27).
  • Laban kissed Joseph (Genesis 29:13).
  • Esau kissed Jacob (Genesis 33:4).
  • Joseph kissed his brethren (Genesis 45:15).
  • Aaron kissed Moses (Exodus 4:27).
  • Moses kissed Jethro (Exodus 18:7).
  • Naomi kissed Ruth and Orpah (Ruth 1:9).
  • David kissed Jonathan (I Samuel 20:41).
  • The father kissed the prodigal son (Luke 15:20).

In these cases from Scripture, the kiss went beyond culture. It carried spiritual and relational meaning, even covenantal like when David and Jonathan made a covenant of friendship.

Why was the holy kiss significant in the early church?

Hence, the instruction to “greet one another with a holy kiss” (Romans 16:16) cultivated a sense of unity and equality among believers. This is what Paul had in mind when he wrote that we should “grow to become in every respect the mature body of him who is the head, that is, Christ. From him the whole body, joined and held together by every supporting ligament, grows and builds itself up in love, as each part does its work” (Ephesians 4:15-16).

For Paul to tell the church to greet one another with a holy kiss would have been a radical statement. Churches in these Roman cities, especially the capital itself, included Jews and Gentiles, people of vastly different ethnic and social groups. To greet with a kiss would have expressed the equality of all people in the church, regardless of class or race.

So for Paul, a Jew and educated Pharisee, to continually urge believers to greet each other with a “holy kiss,” this would have been a sign of family, loyalty, equality, and close kinship between people of different ethnicities and classes, even slaves and masters.

For slaves and masters, Jews and Gentiles, Roman citizens and noncitizens, rich and poor, to all greet one another as such would have been a radical expression to the world of how the church had one identity in Christ and not in the ways of the world. This would have truly set them apart as of another Kingdom.

In the Gospel, Paul brings every believer into this pattern and tradition. As the family of God, the lineage of faith now included any and all who believed. Paul called it holy, set apart by God, different than the world’s idea of a kiss.

Romans 16 and the family of God

In some ways Romans 16 appears to be one of the least-interesting chapters of the New Testament. It consists mostly of Paul’s greetings to a long list of people in Rome. At first glance that doesn’t seem to offer much that would interest us today inasmuch as the names are hard to pronounce and even harder to spell.

Seen in that light, this chapter offers us a rare snapshot of early Christianity. Behind this list of unpronounceable names stands a bedrock truth about the nature of the budding Christian movement and why it had the power to change the ancient world.

But Romans 16 reveals a different side to the great apostle. Here we discover his heart for people. In this chapter he mentions 33 people by name, including 26 people in the church at Rome. He also mentions two others in Rome, but does not name them.

This fact is amazing when you realize that Paul had never been to Rome! Writing to a church he had never visited, he sends greetings to 28 different people.

The church at Rome included the rich and the poor, slaves and freedmen, Jews and Gentiles, Greeks and Romans, forgotten house churches and members of the imperial household. And Paul knew them all by name.

This is a picture of the church the way it ought to be-diverse, multicultural, spanning the human barriers of race, wealth, social class and national background. It’s also a window into Paul’s soul. Despite his serious exterior, deep in his heart Paul was a consummate people person.

“We are family” in Christ

First and foremost, one of the main contributions of the survey was the familial (rather than romantic) nature of kissing in both ancient Israel and the early church. A massive and easily overlooked assumption beneath the apostles’ charge is the familial claim implicit in such instruction.

Christ came to create a social reality that transcends that of blood relatives. He came to establish and build his church, as not only a people who receive his grace and salvation but as a family joined together to him, the elder brother, and through him, to the Father, by faith.

The holy-kiss charge communicates more than simply the implicit “we are family” as brothers and sisters in Christ, but we should not ignore this remarkable reality, nor a second truth which flows from it.

Not only are we, in Christ, family in fact, but we also are to be familial in affection. That is, we come to be like King David, not only in our words and acts but in our affections, when he says of fellow believers in Psalm 16:3, “As for the saints in the land, they are the excellent ones, in whom is all my delight.”

As sinners ourselves, we often find fellow Christians to be some of the hardest people to love. But in our new selves, by the Spirit, the saints - our fellows in Christ, joined also to him - become our delight.

However strange and quirky and annoying and difficult, however foolish and weak by the world’s standards (1 Corinthians 1:26-29), we learn to see our family members in Christ, despite their many flaws, as “excellent ones.”

The holy kiss and sincere affection

The essence of Paul’s instruction in Romans 16:16 is the expression of genuine and sincere affection, regardless of the form it takes: “Let love be genuine. Abhor what is evil; hold fast to what is good. Love one another with brotherly affection. Outdo one another in showing honor” (Romans 12:9-10, ESV).

In other words, express your affection with sincerity, not pretense. When you greet each other, in word or deed, mean it. Don’t flatter or deceive. But first and foremost, genuinely love one another from the heart, as family, brothers and sisters in Christ; then express it genuinely.

Imagine how Judas’s unholy peck of betrayal would have freshly dominated the connotations of the kiss for early Christians. The apostles’ charge for holy kisses means, at least, “Let there be no Judases among us.”

May we never leverage the familial trust of our shared faith in Christ to deceive, use, trick, or exploit other Christians. So, we resolve with every “holy kiss” not to betray or backstab each other, not to “bite and devour one another” (Galatians 5:15).

Rather, we resolve to serve each other, be loyal to each other, love each other in ways that show the world, the flesh, and the devil what kisses are for - not to con or manipulate but to convey heartfelt affection.

The contrast between a holy kiss and Judas’s kiss

We then turned to the two signature instances of kissing in the New Testament, both of them in the life of Christ: the holy kisses of one “woman of the city,” from a heart of love and worship (Luke 7:37-38), and the unholy kiss of betrayal from one of Jesus’s own disciples (Luke 22:47-48).

A kiss on the forehead or beard was a respectful act toward elders or teachers, and this made Judas’ kiss such a deep and hurtful betrayal of Jesus (Luke 22:47).

Surely, “the holy kiss” meant, at least, kissing without lust. But again, kissing in the ancient world (and in Scripture) was far more familial than romantic.

When affectionate ways of greeting one another in Christ become our norm, we may notice more readily emerging breaches in relationship. When we newly feel hesitant to embrace, say, some fellow believer (or extend a handshake, heartfelt word, or warm smile), that may indicate some unaddressed issue that needs attention and resolution (at least in our own hearts).

Just as it’s hard to sincerely pray for someone while remaining angry at him, it would likewise be hard to give someone a “holy kiss” (or whatever culturally appropriate sign) while harboring bitterness.

The holy-kiss charge is a rebuke to any who claim Christ and yet nurse a hard heart toward his people.

The holy kiss and Christian unity

Hence, the instruction to “greet one another with a holy kiss” (Romans 16:16) cultivated a sense of unity and equality among believers.

Often, we allow cultural or social barriers to be expressed in the church. This expresses a lie. These barriers don’t exist in the family of God.

Whatever our culture, we must greet and treat the Body of Christ with honor and intimacy, as true equals in Christ. This means welcoming, accepting, and honoring believers across racial, social, economic, or other boundaries with familial-type affection, with words and actions.

And this expression must be public enough to be seen by the world. Paul challenged the church to practically live out heaven on earth.

Worldly backgrounds and labels (nationality, class, appearance, or our past) don’t impact our identity. In Christ and the Spirit in us, our God identity transcends all others.

We are a holy people, united by the Spirit and adopted into a Kingdom family. God calls us to live in a way that reflects that eternal reality.

Is a literal kiss on the lips required today?

In contemporary Christian communities, the practice of greeting one another with a holy kiss varies greatly. In Western churches, specifically, a kiss is often replaced with a handshake, hug, or head nod-gestures that signify warmth and fellowship.

In some Eastern Orthodox and Middle Eastern churches, however, the tradition of greeting one another with a literal kiss continues to be culturally appropriate.

Christians today, in our differing times and cultures, can feel the freedom not to greet each other with literal kisses. But some still may.

Over the centuries, the practice of greeting one another with a holy kiss adapted to fit various cultural contexts. What remained constant, however, was the godly principle of mutual love and respect for our brothers and sisters in Christ.

The Bible offers guidance on adapting biblical practices to specific cultural contexts. In 1 Corinthians 9:22b, for example, Paul writes, “I have become all things to all people, that by all means I might save some.”

Of course, the core message of the gospel should remain intact, but God allows us to interpret Romans 16:16 according to our cultural context.

What can replace the kiss?

We are enjoined to greet each other - and not without holiness - whether with a hug, handshake, heartfelt word, or whatever similar expression.

We can show such affection through a handshake, a hug, or a warm smile. And I’ve found it important to ask before showing affection in today’s society.

In any event, the heart must remain. Participate in visible affection and unity.

Cultural and personal sensitivities are crucial in applying Romans 16:16. What is appropriate and comfortable in one culture may not be in another. The key is to love one another in a way that respects individual comfort levels.

In Western churches, a handshake can communicate welcome, respect, and fellowship, while a hug or warm smile may express a greater degree of personal affection. The particular gesture is less important than whether it is sincere, appropriate, and received freely.

When you hug someone or when you put a friendly arm around a shoulder or when you greet someone with a holy kiss, you are sending a message that can’t be missed-”I care about you. You’re not alone. We’re in this together.”

Why physical expressions of affection mattered

Let’s hold that radical thought for a moment and ask why the holy kiss was so important in the early church. The answer leads us to a new perspective on Jesus.

In the time of Christ, many of the gods of Greece and Rome were philosophic concepts, deities so far removed from mankind that no one could ever come close. They were like Aristotle’s Unmoved Mover-more an abstract concept than a personal God.

The Gnostics taught that God could never come in contact with human flesh. He was too high, too pure, too holy. And into that world came the touchable God-a little baby.

As he walks the dusty roads of Galilee, he touches the blind and they see. He touches the lame and they walk. Parents bring their children and he takes them in his arms. A woman with a discharge of blood touches his garment and he knows it. A prostitute kisses his feet and he is honored.

He is the touchable God. Not some abstract concept, not a theological proposition. But the Word made flesh and dwelling among us, full of grace and truth.

He was God incarnate walking among us. We are his people. The church is his body.

We do him no justice when we put up a sign that says, “Stay away. Do not touch. I want my space.”

Strange as it may seem, when we greet one another with a holy kiss or holy hug, we are reenacting the very heart of our Christian faith. We are a touchable people because we are children of a touchable God.

Historical practice in the early church

It’s interesting to read the history of the holy kiss. Evidently it was widely practiced in the first few centuries of the Christian church.

We’re told that during the worship service there would a time of greeting in which the men would kiss the men and the women the women-on the cheek or the forehead or in the case of the men, on the beard.

It was a sign of the intense family relationship in the early church. They didn’t just talk about being a family, they were a family and the holy kiss served as a symbol of their love for each other.

It was a holy kiss because it was exchanged between holy people. It was a holy kiss because they truly felt they were brothers and sisters in one big, happy family.

The holy kiss was the normal greeting between Christians. One document from the early church gives this instruction: “Let the deacon say to the people, ’let no one have any quarrel against another; let no one come in hypocrisy. Then, let the men give the men, and women the women, the Lord’s kiss. But let no one do it with deceit as Judas betrayed the Lord with a kiss.’”

Augustine said of the early Christians, “They demonstrated their inward peace by their outward kiss.” Cyril of Jerusalem said, “This kiss is a sign that our souls are united and that we banish all remembrance of injury.” Bishop Cyprian went so far as to say Christians should be “love doves” who exchange the kiss as a mark of innocent affection.

Over time the kiss became a regular part of the worship service. Then it was joined with the Lord’s Supper.

Eventually voices were raised in warning about possible abuse. By the fourth century, it was no longer a spontaneous practice. A few centuries later, it disappeared from the Christian church except as part of the formal liturgy.

Today it is still practiced in the Orthodox Church and in other churches also.

Examples of the holy kiss in different cultures

There are still cultures where the holy kiss is practiced today. I’ll never forget my first trip to St. Petersburg, Russia with John and Helen Sergey.

When the men of the Temple of the Gospel greeted John, one after another they hugged him and warmly kissed him on the cheek. The women did the same for Helen. And so it was in every church we visited.

It was real and genuine and a mark of Christian love. Not only did it not seem strange, once I got used to it, it seemed profoundly biblical.

I didn’t feel like a stranger any more; I felt like a brother in Christ.

Years ago, while living in Korea, I periodically taught how the New Testament says several times to greet a brother with a holy kiss. My goal was to teach this as a symbol to treat the local fellowship like family.

Truly, my goal was never to have people actually kiss one another. Instead, I used the apostle Paul’s clear instruction to point to how we should express the spiritual closeness we have with other disciples in Christ.

My wife and I taught at an international Christian school, and we had a type of “handyman,” Mr. Song. An elderly Korean man, Mr. Song was an amazing man of God and truly served us, treating us like family.

Korean men will hold hands in public as a sign of friendship, affection, and brotherhood. Once, while walking with Mr. Song down a crowded street, he reached out and took my hand.

He was communicating to the world how this young American was his brother, his close friend, crossing cultural and generational boundaries. He took a Korean cultural expression and made it holy.

Applying Romans 16:16 in church life

We might then check ourselves with every “holy kiss,” whether a literal kiss (if acceptable still in some places) or in every kind word of greeting, expression of affection, handshake, or hug to a fellow Christian:

  • Do I really manifest the new birth I have in Jesus, the heart that first loves God and also loves those who too have been born of him (1 John 5:1)?
  • Are my demonstrations of affection toward other believers sincere expressions of love?
  • Are my greetings holy, like that of the redeemed “woman of the city” in Luke 7?
  • Or are they deceptive, even conniving, and unholy like the Judas kiss?

The holy kiss also reminds us of an important dynamic in corporate worship, to ready our hearts for each Sunday. Indeed, we gather to worship Jesus - and we gather that we might do so together.

Which might lead to an application almost as uncomfortable to modern people as a kiss of greeting: slowing down.

What if we considered how hurried we are before and after worship - how late to arrive before the call to worship, and how quick to rush off to lunch or the next event?

We will hardly greet each other with sincere expressions of holy, familial affection without the time and space to greet each other at all.

And if we can’t say that in church, where can we say it? And if we’re embarrassed to say that in church, why are we here in the first place?

The holy-kiss charge is a rebuke to any who would claim Christ and yet nurse a critical disposition toward his people.

It exposes the folly of Christians who would claim to love our brother Jesus but find his other brothers and sisters merely annoying, or maddening, or to be flattered or exploited.

So, we resolve with every “holy kiss” not to betray or backstab each other, not to “bite and devour one another” (Galatians 5:15). Rather, we resolve to serve each other, be loyal to each other, love each other in ways that show the world, the flesh, and the devil what kisses are for - not to con or manipulate but to convey heartfelt affection.

We greet each other, as family, with sincere love - and resolve to live consistently with our greetings.

noimgs

tags: #is #a #holy #kiss #on #the