In the Apostles’ Creed, “He descended into hell” means that after His death Jesus Christ descended to the realm of the dead, not that He was punished in the hell of the damned. The expression is connected with 1 Peter 3:18-22, where Christ is described as being “put to death in the flesh but made alive in the spirit” and as having gone to proclaim something “to the spirits in prison.”
There are three major interpretations of 1 Peter 3:18-20: Christ preached through Noah before the Incarnation; Christ proclaimed His victory to fallen angels; or Christ descended in His soul to the realm of the dead and proclaimed the Good News. The third interpretation is the traditional Catholic reading and is also one of the most ancient interpretations, although the passage has remained difficult and has been interpreted in different ways by faithful biblical interpreters.
What Does the KJV Mean by “Preached unto the Spirits in Prison”?
The King James Version says that Christ was “put to death in the flesh, but quickened by the Spirit: By which also he went and preached unto the spirits in prison” (1 Peter 3:18-19). In this translation, “preached” can suggest that Jesus offered the Gospel to people who had already died, perhaps giving them a second opportunity for salvation.
However, the Greek verb translated “preached” is kerusso, which means “to herald,” “proclaim,” or “announce.” The word is derived from keryx, meaning “herald.” The word only means “preach” in the sense of “giving the King’s message as His royal ambassador.”
The word kerusso does not always have the precise technical meaning of giving a Gospel appeal. The words employed in the New Testament often do take on technical meanings, but Greek existed long before it was ever applied to the Bible, and most of the basic vocabulary has secular or pagan base meanings.
For example, Noah is described as preaching or proclaiming righteousness, John the Baptist as proclaiming a baptism of repentance, and Moses as being proclaimed. The unbelieving Jews of Romans 2:21 are also said to proclaim that people should not steal. These examples show that the word can describe an official announcement without necessarily meaning an invitation to receive salvation.
The Three Main Interpretations of 1 Peter 3:18-20
| Interpretation | Meaning of “the spirits in prison” | Main support | Main difficulty |
|---|---|---|---|
| Christ preached through Noah | The people of Noah’s generation, now imprisoned after death | 1 Peter 1:10-11; Augustine and Aquinas | The passage appears to be discussing Christ’s Passion, Death, Resurrection, and Ascension |
| Christ proclaimed victory to fallen angels | Wicked angels imprisoned because of their rebellion in the days of Noah | Genesis 6; 1 Enoch; the meaning of “spirits” as angels | 1 Peter 4:6 speaks of the Gospel being preached to the dead |
| Christ descended to the realm of the dead | The departed souls awaiting the coming of the Savior | 1 Peter 4:6; ancient Christian interpretation; Catechism of the Catholic Church | “Made alive in the spirit” sounds more naturally like resurrection than descent |
Option One: Christ Preached Through Noah Before the Incarnation
The first interpretation says that 1 Peter 3 describes Christ’s preincarnate preaching through Noah. According to this view, Christ did not descend to the dead after the Crucifixion. Instead, the eternal Word preached through Noah to Noah’s generation while the ark was being built.
Peter writes that Christ “went and preached to the spirits in prison, who formerly did not obey, when God’s patience waited in the days of Noah, during the building of the ark, in which a few, that is, eight persons, were saved through water.” According to this interpretation, the phrase “in the days of Noah” identifies the time when the preaching took place.
This view is supported by Augustine of Hippo and Thomas Aquinas. Both held that Peter was referring to Jesus preaching in the Spirit before the Incarnation through Noah’s mouth.
Although Jesus took flesh in time through the Incarnation, the Word who became flesh is eternal. Many Church Fathers taught that when God speaks in the Old Testament, the speaker should not automatically be understood as the Father. They argued that the Word, the second person of the Trinity, spoke through the Spirit before becoming man.
First Peter 1:10-11 supports this understanding by saying that the prophets “inquired what person or time was indicated by the Spirit of Christ within them when predicting the sufferings of Christ and the subsequent glory.” Peter therefore speaks of the Spirit of Christ working through the prophets to announce the future sufferings and glory of Christ.
Isaiah 53 provides a clear example of this prophetic witness. According to 1 Peter 1, the Spirit inspiring Isaiah was not merely the Spirit of God in an indistinct sense, but the Spirit of Christ indicating the sufferings of the coming Servant.
According to Augustine and Aquinas, the statement that Christ was “made alive in the spirit” and preached to the spirits in prison means that the Spirit of Christ preached through Noah to Noah’s generation. That generation was wicked and disobedient and did not listen to Noah’s call to repentance before the Flood.
The weakness of this interpretation is that the wider context of 1 Peter 3:18-22 appears to be the Paschal Mystery: Christ’s Passion, Death, Resurrection, and Ascension. The interpretation seems to move away from that immediate context and return to the preincarnate existence of the Word.
Nevertheless, this is a respected and venerable interpretation held by Augustine and Aquinas, two of the greatest Fathers and Doctors of the Western Church.
Option Two: Christ Proclaimed Victory to Fallen Angels
The second interpretation, which is popular among many modern commentators, says that 1 Peter describes Christ’s proclamation of victory to fallen angels after His death.
According to this view, when Peter says that Christ was “made alive in the spirit” and went to preach to “the spirits in prison,” he is referring to Christ’s Resurrection and to the wicked angels confined in a spiritual prison.
Jesus is understood to have journeyed to the spiritual prison of the wicked angels in order to proclaim the victory He had accomplished over them through His Passion and Death.
The Connection with Genesis 6
This interpretation is supported by early Jewish writings from the time of Jesus and Peter, including 1 Enoch and the Book of Jubilees. These writings are not part of the Old Testament, but they belong to a body of literature called the Pseudepigrapha. They were widely read, copies of 1 Enoch were found among the Dead Sea Scrolls, and the Letter of Jude quotes 1 Enoch.
There was a widespread Jewish belief that the wicked angels were involved in the corruption of humanity before the Flood. Genesis 6 speaks of the “sons of God” taking the “daughters of men,” and their offspring are associated with violence and corruption on the earth.
In the Book of Enoch, the angels took human form, joined themselves to human women, and produced offspring who corrupted the earth. Whether or not one accepts every detail of that interpretation, the connection between Genesis 6, the violence before the Flood, and the wicked spiritual powers is clear enough to explain why some interpreters identify the “spirits” in 1 Peter with fallen angels.
On this reading, “the spirits in prison” means the wicked angels associated with the days of Noah. The interpretation explains the references to “the days of Noah” and to “spirits” as supernatural beings.
The New Testament sometimes uses the word “spirit” for a wicked angel. In Mark 1:27, people marvel that Jesus commands “even the unclean spirits,” and they obey Him. “Unclean spirit” is a Jewish expression for a fallen angel or evil spiritual being.
The Meaning of Christ’s Proclamation
On this interpretation, Christ did not preach salvation to the fallen angels. He proclaimed His victory over them. They were among the last to learn that their hopes of victory had been defeated by the death and resurrection of the One who died on behalf of sinners.
The verb kerusso means to herald or proclaim. It does not necessarily mean to give a Gospel appeal. The text does not say that Christ proclaimed “righteousness,” “a baptism of repentance,” or “the Gospel” to these spirits. What He proclaimed must be determined from the context.
If the spirits were fallen angels, Christ announced His victory on the cross to beings who had opposed God and His people. The proclamation brought salvation not to them, but to the believers whom they had sought to destroy.
Difficulties with the Fallen-Angel Interpretation
One difficulty is found in 1 Peter 4:6: “For this is why the gospel was preached even to the dead, that though judged in the flesh like men, they might live in the spirit like God.” It is difficult to reconcile the interpretation of 1 Peter 3 as a proclamation to wicked angels with a later statement about the Gospel being preached to the dead.
“The dead” normally refers to human beings who have died, not to angels. Even if fallen angels are punished, they are pure spirits and do not die in the same bodily sense as human beings.
Another difficulty is that the interpretation has little support among the Church Fathers. It is a relatively modern scholarly hypothesis. That does not prove it to be wrong, but it does make it less firmly rooted in the early Christian tradition.
Some interpreters also argue that Peter appears to understand the spirits as human beings because he describes them as having been disobedient “in the days of Noah, while the ark was being prepared.”
Option Three: Christ Descended to the Realm of the Dead
The third interpretation is the one most closely associated with the traditional doctrine that Christ descended into hell, or Hades, after His Crucifixion on Good Friday and before His Resurrection on Easter Sunday.
In this interpretation, 1 Peter 3:18-22 refers to the descent of Christ’s soul into the realm of the dead. “Hell” in the Apostles’ Creed does not mean the place of final damnation where the condemned suffer eternally. It means the realm of the dead: Sheol in Hebrew and Hades in Greek.
Christ was “put to death in the flesh but made alive in the spirit.” On this reading, “made alive in the spirit” does not primarily refer to His bodily Resurrection. Rather, it describes His soul living and acting after His bodily death as He entered the realm of the dead.
There He proclaimed the Gospel, the Good News of redemption, to the souls of the Old Covenant who were awaiting the coming of the Savior.
First Peter 4:6 is closely connected with this interpretation: “For this is why the gospel was preached even to the dead.” The descent of Christ to the realm of the dead explains why Peter speaks of the Gospel being preached to the dead.
Christ entered the prison of souls, the realm of Hades, Sheol, or the underworld, in order to proclaim the Good News of redemption to those who were awaiting deliverance. He went there as the victor of the cross, before His Resurrection and Ascension into heaven.
What “Hell” Means in the Apostles’ Creed
Yes, Jesus really went to hell in the sense intended by the Apostles’ Creed. After He died, Christ’s soul descended to the realm of the dead, not to the hell of the damned.
He did not go there to suffer punishment. He went as Savior to proclaim the Good News of redemption to the souls awaiting deliverance.
There are three compartments in the netherworld, all distinctly separated from one another, any one of which or all three collectively are sometimes referred to as “hell” or “Hades.”
- Paradise was the place of residence for believers after death until Christ’s Ascension to the third heaven; believers now go there after death to await the resurrection.
- Torments, or hell or Hades proper, was and remains the place of unbelievers until the final judgment, when they will be thrown into the lake of fire.
- Tartarus, or the Abyss, is the place of incarceration for fallen angels who have been temporarily put out of action for particular offenses, including the angels associated with the events described in Genesis 6.
In this framework, Christ’s descent does not mean that He entered the place of the damned to endure their punishment. It means that He entered the realm of the dead and proclaimed His victory and redemption.
Strengths and Weaknesses of This Interpretation
The weakness of this interpretation is that “made alive in the spirit” sounds more like resurrection than the descent of Christ’s soul. It is an unusual way to refer to the soul descending into hell.
Its strength is that it makes sense of 1 Peter 4:6. Otherwise, it is difficult to explain what Peter means when he says that the Gospel was preached even to the dead.
Another major strength is its antiquity. It is the most ancient interpretation of 1 Peter 3. Clement of Alexandria and other early Church Fathers understood the passage in this way.
The interpretation also corresponds to the traditional understanding of the Apostles’ Creed and to the teaching presented in the Catechism of the Catholic Church.
What the Catechism Teaches About Christ’s Descent
The Catechism of the Catholic Church favors the interpretation that Christ descended in His soul to the realm of the dead and proclaimed the Good News to the departed souls awaiting the Savior.
The Catechism states:
“The frequent New Testament affirmations that Jesus was ‘raised from the dead’ presuppose that the crucified one sojourned in the realm of the dead prior to his resurrection. This was the first meaning given in the apostolic preaching to Christ’s descent into hell: that Jesus, like all men, experienced death and in his soul joined the others in the realm of the dead. But he descended there as Savior, proclaiming the Good News to the spirits imprisoned there.”
This is Catechism of the Catholic Church, paragraph 632, which cites 1 Peter 3:18-19 in its footnote.
The Catechism’s statement is not an infallible definition from an ecumenical council. It represents the ordinary teaching of the Church: Christ went in His soul to the realm of the dead and proclaimed the Good News to the souls awaiting the coming of the Savior.
Does 1 Peter Teach Salvation After Death?
The traditional interpretation does not mean that Christ offered condemned sinners a second opportunity to repent after death. The Bible does not teach salvation to sinners once they have died and gone to hell.
Everything known from Scripture indicates that this life is the opportunity to come to the Lord and that after death judgment awaits. Hebrews 9:27 says that it is appointed for people once to die and after that comes judgment.
The idea that Christ preached to unbelievers in hell in order to give them an opportunity to accept Him creates serious difficulties. If salvation remained available after death, everyone in hell would have an opportunity to escape. Such a view would conflict with the biblical teaching concerning salvation and faith during this life.
Luke 16:19-31 also presents a fixed gulf between the rich man in torment and Lazarus in Abraham’s bosom. The rich man asks that someone be sent to warn his brothers, but Abraham replies that they have Moses and the prophets. He says that if they do not listen to Moses and the prophets, they will not believe even if someone rises from the dead.
The passage indicates that the decisive question is faith during this life. It does not present Hades as a place from which the condemned may escape through a later decision.
The rich man, who had not given himself to God while alive, becomes willing to receive a warning after experiencing torment. This shows why a decision made in hell would not be a free response to God. No one would willingly choose to remain in torment if there were any way to escape it.
Therefore, Christ’s descent should not be understood as an offer of salvation to the damned. It is better understood as His proclamation of redemption and victory to the dead, especially the righteous who awaited the coming of the Savior.
Christ’s Proclamation to Fallen Angels
A different interpretation holds that Christ proclaimed His victory to fallen angels imprisoned in the Abyss. This interpretation also denies that Christ offered salvation to sinners after death.
According to this view, the spirits in 1 Peter 3:19-20 are not human souls but fallen angels associated with the events before the Flood. Christ announced His victory over them, but He did not invite them to repentance or offer them redemption.
This interpretation takes seriously the reference to the spirits who were disobedient in the days of Noah and the New Testament use of “spirit” for evil spiritual beings.
It also emphasizes that kerusso means “proclaim” or “herald,” not necessarily “preach the Gospel in order to secure conversion.” The proclamation could therefore be an announcement of judgment and victory.
The principal difficulty is the relationship between 1 Peter 3:19 and 1 Peter 4:6. The former refers to “spirits in prison,” while the latter says that the Gospel was preached to “the dead.” The two passages may be interpreted differently, but the relationship between them remains a central issue in evaluating the passage.
The Interpretation That Christ Preached Through Noah
Another interpretation says that Christ’s preaching occurred during Noah’s lifetime rather than after Christ’s death. On this view, Noah was the “herald of righteousness,” as Peter calls him in 2 Peter 2:5.
Noah preached in the power of the Holy Spirit, whom Peter earlier calls “the Spirit of Christ.” The men and women of Noah’s generation rejected that proclamation even though God patiently delayed judgment while the ark was being prepared.
Because of their former disobedience, they are now “in prison,” meaning that their souls were committed to punishment after death.
This reading gives a natural force to the expression “in the days of Noah.” Peter would be referring to the time of the preaching rather than to the time when the people were imprisoned.
It also avoids the need to identify a special preaching mission to only one generation of the dead. The people of Noah’s generation heard the proclamation while they were alive, and they were judged after refusing it.
The main difficulty is that the immediate context appears to focus on Christ’s Passion, Death, Resurrection, and Ascension. The interpretation therefore has to understand Peter as moving from Christ’s death and resurrection back to the Spirit’s work through Noah before the Incarnation.
1 Peter 4:6 and “The Gospel Was Preached to the Dead”
First Peter 4:6 says: “For this is why the gospel was preached even to the dead, that though judged in the flesh like men, they might live in the spirit like God.”
The traditional interpretation understands “the dead” as those who were physically dead when Peter wrote. The Gospel was preached to them during their lifetime, and they have since died.
On this reading, Peter is responding to the question of what benefit there is in becoming a Christian if Christians die like other people. His answer is that the preaching of Christ and His Gospel to those who have since died had the purpose that, although they might appear condemned according to human judgment, they might live spiritually before God.
This interpretation understands “preached to the dead” as referring to people who heard the Gospel while alive and later died, not to preaching that occurred after their death.
The alternative interpretation connects 1 Peter 4:6 with Christ’s descent to the dead. In that reading, Christ Himself preached the Gospel to the dead in the realm of Hades.
The relationship between these two passages is one reason why 1 Peter 3:18-20 remains difficult. The passages can be read together as describing Christ’s descent, or they can be read as referring to preaching that occurred during the hearers’ earthly lives.
Luke 23:43 and Paradise
Jesus told the repentant thief, “Today you will be with me in Paradise.” This statement indicates that the repentant thief would be with Christ after death.
One interpretation understands Paradise as the blessed compartment of the realm of the dead, where the righteous awaited the fulfillment of redemption before Christ’s Resurrection and Ascension.
Another interpretation understands Paradise as the presence of God. In either case, the passage does not suggest that the repentant thief entered a defective or hopeless condition from which he needed to be rescued by additional preaching.
The statement does, however, show that Christ’s death did not place Him among the condemned. His descent into the realm of the dead was the saving action of the victorious Messiah.
Why Did Jesus Descend into the Realm of the Dead?
Christ descended into the realm of the dead because He truly experienced human death. The crucified One sojourned among the dead before His Resurrection.
He descended as Savior, not as one who needed redemption. He went as the victor of the cross to proclaim the Good News of redemption.
He did not simply conquer sin on Good Friday and conquer death on Easter Sunday. He also entered the realm of the dead and liberated the souls of the dead by proclaiming the redemption accomplished through His Passion.
The descent therefore shows the complete reach of Christ’s saving work. His victory extends to the living and the dead, to earth and the realm beneath the earth, and to every power that opposes God.
Christ’s descent is also connected with His victory over spiritual powers. First Peter 3:21-22 speaks of Jesus Christ’s Resurrection, Ascension, and authority over angels, authorities, and powers.
Holy Saturday Is Also Good News
Holy Saturday is sometimes treated as a quiet interval between Good Friday and Easter Sunday. The doctrine of Christ’s descent shows that it is also a day of Gospel proclamation.
As Christians prepare to celebrate the mystery of Christ’s Passion and Death, they should not forget the mystery of Holy Saturday, the day of Christ’s descent into hell. His descent is itself Good News.
Jesus does not merely conquer sin on Good Friday and death on Easter Sunday. He also liberates the souls of the dead from the realm of the dead by proclaiming the Good News of their redemption.
This is the great mystery of Holy Saturday remembered each year during the sacred Triduum.
How the Passage Relates to Christian Hope
First Peter 3:18-22 was written to Christians who were experiencing opposition and persecution. Peter tells believers to be prepared to give an answer to anyone who asks for the reason for the hope within them.
Noah provides an example of faithful witness. While the ark was being built, he testified to the coming judgment of God even though the surrounding generation rejected his message.
Christians likewise are called to testify to the hope of the Gospel before a world that may mock and scorn them in unbelief.
They do so in the power of the Holy Spirit, the Spirit of Christ who worked in Noah’s proclamation and by whom Christ was raised from the dead.
Their task is not futile. The risen Jesus has won the victory. Believers should neither fear nor despair, but should regard Christ the Lord as holy in their hearts and tell others about Him.
Jesus is on His throne and at work among His people by His Spirit. Christians are called to remain faithful and serve Him in their own generation.
How Should “Preached” Be Understood in the KJV?
The KJV word “preached” should not automatically be taken to mean that Jesus delivered a sermon inviting the dead to become believers. The underlying Greek word, kerusso, is broader than that.
A better translation in this context may be “proclaimed.” The word describes the action of a herald announcing an authoritative message on behalf of a king.
When the subject is the Gospel, the herald proclaims the Good News of salvation through faith in the person and work of Jesus Christ. But the same word can describe the proclamation of righteousness, repentance, divine judgment, the Law, or Christ’s victory.
Consequently, the meaning of “preached” in 1 Peter 3:19 must be determined by the entire context, not by assuming that kerusso always means an appeal for conversion.
Does the Bible Contradict Itself on This Subject?
The biblical passages concerning Christ’s descent are difficult, but they need not be understood as contradictory.
Hebrews 9:27 teaches that people die once and then face judgment. Luke 16:19-31 describes a fixed separation between the righteous and the wicked after death. These passages do not support the idea of salvation being offered to the condemned after death.
First Peter 3:18-20 can therefore be understood as describing an authoritative proclamation rather than a second chance for repentance. The proclamation may be Christ’s announcement of victory to fallen angels, Christ’s preaching through Noah before the Flood, or Christ’s proclamation of redemption to the righteous dead awaiting the Savior.
The three interpretations differ in their understanding of the identity of the spirits and the time of the proclamation. They agree that the passage does not teach that condemned sinners can secure salvation after death by believing in Christ in the realm of punishment.
Why the Passage Remains Difficult
Peter’s statement is one of the most difficult passages in the New Testament. The wording is brief, the identity of “the spirits” is not explicitly explained, and the relationship between verses 18-20 and the surrounding discussion requires careful interpretation.
Peter himself says that Paul’s letters contain some things that are hard to understand. The same can be said of Peter’s letters.
Faithful interpreters have therefore reached different conclusions. Some emphasize the connection with Noah and understand Christ as preaching through him. Others emphasize the language of spiritual imprisonment and identify the spirits as fallen angels. Still others emphasize the ancient Christian tradition, the Apostles’ Creed, and 1 Peter 4:6 and understand Christ as descending to the realm of the dead.
The Catechism favors the third interpretation, while other Christian interpreters prefer the first or second. The existence of these differences does not alter the central confession that Christ truly died, that He entered the realm of the dead, and that He rose victorious.
