Feminism and Catholicism are not automatically mutually opposed. At its core, feminism is about promoting the dignity and equality of women, but that can mean different things for different people. A woman can be a Catholic stay-at-home mother and be a feminist, just as a woman can be a workaholic CEO and be a feminist.
The relationship between feminism and Catholicism combines substantial points of convergence with serious disagreements. Both traditions can affirm the dignity of women, oppose discrimination, value social responsibility and support human flourishing, while differing sharply over women’s ordination, contraception, abortion, sexuality, gender identity and the meaning of equality.
What feminism means in a Catholic context
“Feminism is an umbrella term.” “Theological literacy is low.” “There is a lot of misinformation about both feminism and theology. Rather than being mutually opposed, they should be mutually informed.”
At its core, feminism is about promoting the dignity and equality of women, but that can mean different things for different people. Feminism is not saying all women should take birth control, get abortions, work as CEOs or never have children. It’s saying that women have dignity and deserve to be honored in the same way that men are, and as such, should be able to make choices based on their values and goals.
A woman can be a Catholic stay-at-home mother and be a feminist. A woman can be a workaholic CEO and be a feminist. A woman can be 17 and pregnant, choose to have an abortion and be a feminist. A woman can be 17 and pregnant, choose not to terminate the pregnancy and be a feminist. A woman can believe that she should be able to be ordained by the Catholic church and be a feminist, and a woman can believe that women should not be ordained by the church and still be a feminist.
The language used to discuss feminism, and the language used to discuss Catholicism rarely align. Because so many people associate feminism with radicalism, they turn away from it out of fear of being considered radical themselves.
Why the two traditions are often considered incompatible
Oftentimes people get hung up on the most controversial issues, like women’s ordination and abortion. To reduce feminist theology to two issues loses sight of all feminism has done to make profound social changes for women around the world.
Many people associate feminism with radicalism, while Catholic institutions and officials have often treated some feminist claims as threats to religious tradition, family life or established teachings about human nature. This stalemate causes rifts between old and new and is a large reason why the church is considered traditional and modern movements radical.
There will, of course, be the need for nuanced historical, cultural, and geographic studies. Neither Catholicism nor feminism can be encapsulated in a bullet point on an outline. The tensions between the two are not the same in the United States as they are in sub-Saharan Africa.
At the same time, nuanced rigorous comparative analysis of the normative frameworks of Catholicism and feminism sorely needs to be undertaken. Facilitating this sort of analysis, of course, is a central purpose of the “Contending Modernities” project, which will unfold over a period of several years.
Feminism and Catholicism in the twentieth century
Early Catholic women’s activism
Historically, there has been little contact between Christian women and feminists in France since the end of the 19th century, even if some encounters did take place and have been documented. From the 1890s, a magazine such as La Femme contemporaine [The Contemporary Woman] edited by Abbot Lagardère, was able to defend the right to vote as well as its loyalty to the Catholic magisterium.
Studies of the Ligue Patriotique des Françaises [The Frenchwomen’s Patriotic League] have however clearly shown how certain female Catholic activists rejected secular, republican universalism in the early 20th century. They favoured instead a political identity that refused neutrality, through strong involvement in the health and welfare sector.
Perhaps more originally, in the interwar period, a branch of the Alliance Jeanne d’Arc [the Joan of Arc Alliance] was set up in France, campaigning for the priesthood to be opened up to women. However, this type of experience was marginal.
It only involved a limited number of avant-garde Catholic intellectuals, like Cécile de Corlieu, Cécile Brunschwig, or Pauline Archambault. Does this explain the relative withdrawal of Catholic women from post-war feminist movements? This may be a question of perspective.
Dialogue with second-wave feminism
Female theoreticians who also criticised the idea that gender is a self-evident category determined by nature may have used the religious discourses of exegesis or theology as intellectual resources to justify and think about their emancipation.
We can observe an intellectual dialogue between feminism and Catholicism as early as the 1960s, even though little is known about it. Few may now recall the 1967 book by Catholic Yvonne Pellé-Douël, Être femme, which hailed Simone de Beauvoir’s work as “the first and perhaps the only work that deals frankly with women’s issues and which, on many fundamental points, has opened up paths which we can no longer ignore”.
A Professor of philosophy and activist for academic cooperation in Cameroon, Yvonne Pellé-Douël, wanted Christian women to carry out Simone de Beauvoir’s work “based on their existence as women committed to their faith in Christ”. Her philosophy was however connected to a very specific context, that of 1960s Catholicism, a period marked by the Vatican II Council (1962-1965), which hailed “the promotion of women”.
Among the psychedelia of the early ’60s was Betty Friedan, author of “The Feminine Mystique.” Entirely radical to the time period, the book was a catalyst for sparking what is typically referred to as the second wave of American feminism.
While the first wave of American feminism was based in legal advancement - the right to vote - the second wave was based in existentialism. The big question posed in Friedan’s novel asked why a woman’s role in society was so cut and dry.
Simply put, “is this all there is?” In other words, why is it assumed that women are only capable of raising children and keeping the house?
Feminist theology after Vatican II
This opening up led to the reconfiguration of Catholic feminism, as symbolised in France and Belgium by the foundation of the Femmes et Hommes dans l’Église [Women and Men in the Church] association in 1969-1970.
This provided an original, association-based and non-academic hub, around which women such as Marie-Thérèse van Lunen Chenu, Renée Dufour, Alice Gombault, Suzanne Tunc and Françoise Vandermeersch gravitated, their various publications embodying a genuine intellectual link between Christian heritage and certain aspects of second wave feminism.
Several of the issues they investigated chimed with the concerns of feminist research as it developed over the following decades, namely their interest in the historic construction of male/female categories within Christianity and the church, as well as their nuanced criticism of essentialism, whether it imprisons women inside motherhood or other specific social stereotypes.
But the difficulties that this movement encountered were more of a structural than an intellectual nature. Unlike what happened in English-speaking countries, Catholic institutions prevented its legitimation, by refusing to award theology chairs to its authors in spite of their PhDs - a move which would have formalised their work within a visible strand of religious science.
This Christian branch of second wave feminism, far from being merely anecdotal, has nevertheless endured to this day, and drives the “unité de recherche et de documentation Genre en Christianisme” (“Gender in Christianity Research and Documentation Unit”) founded in 2003.
“Genre en Christianisme” is housed in the Parisian Dominican Library of Saulchoir, houses a collection of almost 2,000 publications (including books, specialised journals and academic works) and organises conferences on gender studies in a religious context.
This is one of the rare places where the term “gender” is used positively in the contemporary French Catholic world. But while “Genre en Christianisme” continues to organise seminars, publications and conferences, it remains a very marginal organisation, while gender studies have progressively come into the crosshairs of the Catholic magisterium and certain intellectuals connected to it.

The Catholic Church and women’s dignity
Boston College professor Cathleen Kaveny wrote in an article, “If feminism is ultimately about affirming the dignity and well-being of women, the Roman Catholic Church as a whole is a feminist church in many crucial ways.”
More broadly, if feminism is ultimately about affirming the dignity and well-being of women, we must applaud the many crucial ways in which the Roman Catholic Church as a whole is a feminist Church. It has done an enormous amount of good for women in precarious circumstances throughout the world, Catholic and non-Catholic alike.
For example, the Catholic Agency for Overseas Development, Gender & Women runs programs around the world that help women organize into cooperatives for the production and marketing of goods; provides shelters for basic needs; educational programs in literacy; and training in business knowledge and empowerment.
The Mother Teresa School for Girls in Ghana educates over 550 girls from preschool through high school.
At the same time, it is safe to say that many people don’t share the late Pope’s easy association of feminism and the papacy. In fact, there are some-both feminists and Catholics-who would bristle at the association.
John Paul II and the idea of a “new feminism”
Pope John Paul II’s famous proclamation, “Io sono il Papa feminista,” or “I am the feminist pope,” introduced his ideas, calling for a “new feminism.”
About twelve years ago, I gave a paper at a conference on “Women’s Health and Human Rights” at the Vatican. A highlight of the event was a special audience for the conference participants with Pope John Paul II.
To the surprise and delight of his listeners, he benignly proclaimed “Io sono il Papa feminista”- “I am the feminist pope.” And Pope John Paul II meant it.
In 1988, he had issued an apostolic letter, Mulieris Dignitatem, with the English title On the Dignity and Vocation of Women. He repeatedly called for the development of a “new feminism” which would honor and celebrate the “feminine genius” in all walks of life, public as well as private, in the work world as well as the domestic world.
During his papacy, he published “On the Dignity and Vocation of Women.” However, Kaveny also admits that many people are uncomfortable with the “easy association of feminism and the papacy.”
John Paul II’s papacy, which started in 1978, confirmed these positions through its prolific and ambitious discourse about women which, while making allowances for the issue of a just equality, criticised a “radical” form of feminism that pushed too far its requirements of equality, in particular where contraception and abortion were concerned.
Due to their capacity to give life, women were viewed as possessing intrinsic qualities (care for others, listening, humility) that are requisite for the domestic life that should be their main concern. The diversity of functions was viewed as being grounded in nature, in particular within the ecclesial institution.
Three Catholic polarities in the feminism debate
Here and now, however, I can only briefly suggest that we give some consideration to three normative polarities within the Roman Catholic framework itself, polarities which help illuminate how John Paul II could honestly and truly say that he is a feminist pope, on the one hand, and there could also be significant points of strain between Catholicism and feminism, on the other.
- Equality and difference
- Nature and nurture
- Complementarity and collaboration
Many Catholics see these tensions as creative, and affirm the importance of holding onto both poles in each polarity. Catholics want to affirm, after all, that men and women are equal-and that are not the identical in every significant respect. So, for that matter, do many feminists.
What, then, is the root of the antagonism? In my view, a significant part of it is attributable to fear. Each party fears that the other is in danger of letting go of one pole, to the detriment of women and indeed, to the detriment of all of society.
Equality and difference
On the one hand, the Catholic tradition has long held that all human beings are made in the image and likeness of God, equal in dignity, possessing the same human nature, no matter their sex, race, ethnicity, or social status (Gal. 3:28).
On the other hand, the Church does not see human persons as purely spiritual bundles of reason and will. We don’t merely have bodies, we are embodied, and that embodiment s part of the goodness of God’s creation.
In particular, our different embodiment as either male or female is a divinely ordained aspect of the created order, which needs to be honored and respected if humanity is to flourish.
In a nutshell, the Vatican worries that some strands of secular Western feminism are emphasizing the first point-equality-to the detriment of the second point-difference. It worries that this obscures the ontological difference between men and women, and the goodness of that difference for both individuals and society.
In particular, it fears that an insufficient appreciation of difference will denigrate women’s unique power as mothers, who shape and nurture the next generation.
But the Vatican isn’t the only one who has worries. Feminists are worried too. The way in which some Vatican documents-and some supporters of papal feminism-try to specify these differences between men and women concerns feminists, because it can seem as as if certain character traits are being defined and imposed as either “male” or “female” without any regard for empirical study or individual difference.
And that definition and imposition, they believe, contributes to inequality. Consider, for example, the position of papal feminist Gloria Conde:
Quoting Judith M. Bardwick, she writes: “The ‘masculine’ is equivalent to the objective, analytical, active, inclined to thought, rational, indomitable, interfering, one who obstructs, independent, self-sufficient, emotionally controlled, and self-assured. With his mind, the man distinguishes, analyzes, separates, and perfects. The ‘feminine’ corresponds to the subjective, intuitive, passive, tender, sensitive, easily influenced, docile, receptive, empathetic, dependent, emotional, and conservative. Her mind picks up relations, she possesses intuitive perception of sentiments, and she tends to unite rather than divide.”
The trouble with this sort of sharply dichotomous understanding of the difference between men and women is that it undermines women who are doing jobs that don’t correspond in every respect to the traditional “feminine” virtues.
Nature and nurture
Where do these differences between men and women come from, anyway? This question brings us to a second flash point between Catholicism and feminism: the polarity between nature and nurture.
On the one hand, the Catholic tradition recognizes that human beings are essentially social-our understandings of who we are, of our place in the world, are shaped and transmitted by the languages, cultures, and societies in which we live.
On the other hand, that tradition also proclaims that there is some irreducible core of “human nature” that remains constant across time, place, and culture.
Let me emphasize the importance of the Church’s commitment to the notion of a common human nature. It forms the basis not only for the proclamation of equal human dignity, but also for the tradition’s confidence in the possibility of articulating some basis for a universal morality that transcends particular religious and cultural traditions.
In our cosmopolitan and fractious world, I believe that commitment to human nature will be increasingly indispensable.
The Vatican believes that the secular West has gone too far in endorsing the first pole-nurture-to the detriment of the second pole-nature. It worries that the idea that human nature, including sex and gender, are completely malleable does not give enough weight to the created order, whose intricate pattern is embedded in the physical and psychic structure of human beings.
The Vatican is making an important point. Nature matters. Some differences between males and females seem ingrained, not imposed.
More scientifically, we know that endocrinologists are making great strides in understanding the way in which male and female hormones, such as testosterone and estrogen, affect our brains, and therefore influence our ability to reason and to choose.
The mind and the body are not separate entities. It is a serious anthropological mistake to think of human beings as androgynous minds encased in male or female bodies.
For their part, however, feminists worry that what some people view as the designs of nature are in fact not natural at all, but are in fact the deceptive mask worn by ingrained patterns of sexism.
Consider, for example, the article on “Woman” in the 1913 Catholic Encyclopedia, in which one of the authors maintains that the education of women should be directed toward their roles as wives and mothers.
The author hastens to observe that “the Catholic Church places here no barriers that have not already been established by nature.” While a few women might go on to earn higher degrees, he asserts that “the sexes can never be on an equality as regards studies pursued at a university.”
Ironically, that assertion may be turning out to be correct-just not in the author supposed. A recent study showed that women outnumber men at every degree level in higher education in the United States-even, since last year, with respect to Ph.Ds.
Men still outnumber women in some fields, such as engineering, but overall the educational gap between men and woman has closed, and even begun to reverse itself.
Complementarity and collaboration
With all these women flooding the educational system, men find themselves competing for advancement and academic honor not only with other men, but also with women. Is that worrisome?
Pope Benedict XVI has expressed concern about the increasing relationship of competition between men and women, and calls instead for a collaborative relationship between the sexes. (See, e.g., Joseph Ratzinger, “On the Collaboration of Men and Women in the Church and in the World.”)
In his view, the basis of a collaborative relationship is the recognition of the complementary gifts and skills of men and women. Men and women should view themselves and their roles as complementary, not as competitive; women in particular should not aim to emulate the strengths of men, but should instead nurture their own distinct gifts.
Complementarity, in his view, is most clearly visible in the roles that men and women play in marriage and family life, but it is also should be visible in other contexts as well.
One of the hallmarks of papal feminism, in fact, is an effort to define the “feminine genius” in all spheres of women’s existence in terms of the virtues of motherhood.
For their part, feminists are worried about the call to complementarity, not necessarily because they are opposed to the idea that both men and women bring some distinct and important gifts to human society, but because of the way that idea tends to work out in practice.
In fact, they fear it undermines collaboration, which in Latin means “working together, ” because it tends to promote both separation and practical inequality.
The great Protestant theologian Karl Barth explicated male-female complementarity in terms of A and B; one need not be a psychic accurately to guess which sex is assigned to the B position.
The way the concept of complementarity works in geometry also reveal the potential problem: Two angles are complementary if they add up to 90 degrees. If we begin with a 68 degree angle, then the complementary angle must be 22 degrees.
The complementary angle is all and only that which the primary angle is not. Analogously, if we begin with a man, then a woman must be all and only that which a man is not-her role is to fill in the gaps.
If complementarity is taken too far, then, it does not facilitate collaboration, but rather fosters entirely separate spheres of interest and specialization.
The concept of complementarity notion rightly affirms the importance-and unique demands-of motherhood on women. But how does it account for the gifts, ambitions, and concerns that men and women share in common?
How does it account for the fact that men and women have many of the same talents, as well as different talents? It ought not, in my view, to be considered a destructive form of competition for men and women to strive for excellence-together-in the many areas and interests which they share.
The common pursuit of excellence-or virtue-is also a type of collaboration. In fact, it is a key element of the classical definition of friendship.
The Holy See and the rise of gender debates
Catholic feminist circles are no longer influential enough on a global scale, since they have no institutional support to relay their ideas, and are too few and marginalised within their denominational group to enable a positive reading of gender and feminism to emerge.
At the international level, and particularly in the Holy See, a doctrine that is extremely critical of both contemporary feminism and its theoretical framework has emerged.
Indeed, a very different narrative has developed in Rome in the wake of the Vatican II Council. While John XXIII (1958-1963) broke with his predecessors’ repeated condemnations of the feminist movement’s will to emancipation, this period was an exception.
For Paul VI (1963-1978) and his successors, John Paul II (1978-2005) and Benedict XVI (2005-2013), the acknowledgement of the “essential equality of man and woman from the point of view of their humanity” was only accepted insofar as it did not affect the monopoly of men on certain social roles (priesthood) or on conjugal and sexual morality.
Admittedly, Paul VI did actually commit the Church to the struggle for women’s emancipation, for example by proclaiming 1975 as the “Year of the Woman”, in tune with the UN’s position on the matter.
However, this apparent political convergence quickly gave way to fault lines that have only grown deeper since then. The Inter Insigniores declaration (1976), which ruled out the possibility of changing the Catholic organisation of instituted ministries, clashed above all with a school of thought that had developed considerably since the Council through the development, mainly in the United States, of a feminist theology.
Since then, the Roman magisterium has stuck to the same line of argument. Women do indeed have equal dignity to men. They are neither inferior nor impure, as clerics may have unfortunately and mistakenly taught in the past.
It is right to fight against the discriminations experienced by women. And this fight may be led by Catholics.
However, the Church does not have the right to change Christ’s choice to be incarnated as a man, and to choose men as his apostles.
Some social roles are induced by biology, as are sexual orientations. Any deviation from the “natural” heterosexual norm is the product of a disorder, whose origin is mysterious, and which should awaken compassion and mercy in Churches, but never be legitimised or acknowledged by States (Persona Humana, 1975).
Gender, international institutions and Catholic teaching
Unsurprisingly, when the term “gender” emerged in public debate within feminist movements, university departments and international organisations from the 1990s onwards, it failed to make it over the difficult hurdle of the magisterium.
In 1995, the UN Conference on Women in Beijing agreed to acknowledge that the subordinate position imposed on women in many societies is the result of several interacting factors.
It is not just a product of legal factors (such as access to civil rights), socio-economic factors (access to paid work), nor even of population policies (reproductive rights), but also of more cultural and symbolic aspects.
To advance equality between women and men, it was now recommended that any public policy take into account gender relations (an approach known as “gender mainstreaming”), tackling cultural stereotypes and the social roles assigned to men and women.
In the final text of the conference, the observer from the Holy See worried about the development of “world views which assert that sexual identity can be adapted indefinitely to suit new and different purposes”.
The spirit of that time played against gender. In the previous year, the Cairo UN Conference on population policy and development had outlined the concept of “reproductive rights” at the international level, in order to promote free access to contraception and abortion.
The UN’s position cooled the Holy See’s desire to cooperate with international authorities. At the religious level, roughly at the same time, the Lambeth Conference - the Anglican Church’s instrument of communion - approved the ordination of women priests.
This somewhat validated the interpretation of feminist theology, according to which Christ’s incarnation as a man was the outcome of a historical contingency in Jewish society at the time.
The Catholic critique of “gender ideology”
Going against the modern aspiration to define gender and sexual identities separately from biologically assigned sex, Rome has since then been tirelessly condemning gender studies through various channels.
In 2003, the Pontifical Council for the Family published a Lexicon of Ambiguous and Debatable Terms Regarding Family Life and Ethical Questions. The book aims at explaining to Catholics the meaning of expressions that have become “problematic” in the modern age.
The term “gender”, as put forward by the UN in its final report on the 1995 Conference, is seen as the smokescreen of a subversive ideology produced by radical American feminists.
One article is devoted to “verbal engineering”. It claims that a minority of players are trying to impose their views within international authorities in order to promote social change through language.
These “coded words” include “gender”of course, defined as “a substitute for the word sex” that is used by “many feminists”.
No less than three articles are in fact devoted to criticising this term. Overall, the text rules out any possibility of a positive use of the concept of gender.
Gender is presented in the dictionary on three levels, as a “concept”, an “ideology” and a “theory”, as the product of a radical feminist movement which Catholics must defend themselves against.
In France, gender was mentioned much later in official Catholic documents, almost ten years after the Beijing Conference. In 2005, during its plenary assembly, the Conference of Catholic Bishops presented gender as a “priority area”, and tasked a commission with drawing up a reference document.
The work was coordinated by Jacques Arènes, a psychoanalyst. It led to the publication of a document entitled “La problématique du genre” (“The Issue of Gender”).
While less virulent than the Roman declarations, this text nevertheless asserts that what it refers to as “gender theory” goes further than “gender studies”, and “constitutes the ideological body of work used by gay lobbies to defend the ideas they submit to legislative authorities, in particular so-called gay marriage”(p. 3).
Benedict XVI and modernity
After being appointed as Pope in 2005 under the name Benedict XVI, Josef Ratzinger made this condemnation more stringent. He explicitly referred to gender while presenting his Christmas wishes to the Curia in 2008.
According to him, the criticism of “gender” was now part of a general criticism of modernity, which was engaged in a vain race towards a type of autonomy that had forgotten about nature:
“What is often expressed and understood by the term ‘gender’ ultimately ends up being man’s attempt at self-emancipation from creation and the Creator”.
According to this much-publicised speech, the safeguard of creation and ecology must involve defending heterosexual marriage. If social norms tend to be nothing more than pure conventions that forget Creation, then nature is in danger.
Benoît XVI renewed his condemnation in Christmas 2012. Commenting Simone de Beauvoir’s sentence: “One is not born, but rather becomes, a woman”, the pope saw in it the “foundation for what is put forward today under the term “gender” as a new philosophy of sexuality".
Women’s ordination, sexuality and reproductive ethics
Secular feminists have frequently decried Catholicism as opposed to the flourishing of women, in particular its opposition of contraception and abortion.
For their part, officials in the Vatican have regularly published broad denunciations of feminism, castigating its destructive effects on society and the family, particularly children, both born and unborn.
While the Catholic magisterium recognizes the equal dignity of women, it does not accept that this equality necessarily requires equal access to every ecclesial role.
The Inter Insigniores declaration (1976), which ruled out the possibility of changing the Catholic organisation of instituted ministries, clashed above all with a school of thought that had developed considerably since the Council through the development, mainly in the United States, of a feminist theology.
Some Catholics support the Church’s restriction of the priesthood to males, while others believe that women should be ordained. These positions demonstrate why Catholic feminism cannot be reduced to one uniform political or theological program.
Even women who support the Church’s restriction of the priesthood to males winced at the grouping of these two acts in the same document.
Feminist theology and internal Catholic pluralism
The Catholic reception of feminist studies and then, since the 1990s, of gender studies, could be the subject of a cultural history. This article questions the idea that Catholicism’s response to feminist studies, and to their offshoot in the form of gender studies, is exclusively negative.
While the Catholic magisterium, whose positions are relayed by some intellectuals, tends overall to condemn both the concept of gender and its uses in the social sciences, and while its bishops, through episcopal conferences or apostolic nuncios to the UN and European authorities, fight against its applications in international law and its transcriptions into national law, there are also, at the grassroots level, some unique, original and often little-known experiences of dialogue and acceptance of the concept of gender.
These illustrate the internal pluralism, the adaptability and the relative flexibility of contemporary Catholicism.
Catholic women lie on a wide spectrum of politics and those who advocate for women’s rights are often overlooked. Now, more than ever, it seems as though the divide between Church and state is becoming murky.
The hope for this page is that resources have been collected to bring light to the works of so many influential Catholic feminists.
The Christian branch of second wave feminism has endured to this day, and drives the “unité de recherche et de documentation Genre en Christianisme” (“Gender in Christianity Research and Documentation Unit”) founded in 2003.
However, Catholic feminist circles are no longer influential enough on a global scale, since they have no institutional support to relay their ideas, and are too few and marginalised within their denominational group to enable a positive reading of gender and feminism to emerge.
Catholic institutions in contemporary life
Being at a Catholic Jesuit institution in 2015 is a unique experience. We get to see the modern world collide with a traditional dogma.
The interaction is often positive. For example, Marquette offers LGBTQ Masses. That’s not something you would have seen in 1963.
But where is the line drawn? The church can’t abandon all tradition in an attempt to appease the trends of the modern world, but it also can’t ignore the modern world and the ideas that have developed.
This tension appears in universities, parishes, social organizations and families. Catholic institutions can promote service, unity and compassion while still maintaining teachings that many feminists regard as restrictive or unequal.
Many Catholic women find themselves caught in the middle, loving their Church and their faith, but dispirited by occasional statements that suggest that the Vatican views them as disordered or defiled, simply by virtue of their being women.
Equality, agency and disagreement
Going back to Baumgardt, saying that feminism and Catholicism should be mutually informing rather than mutually opposed, the ultimate goal for the relationship between feminism and the church should not be to convince anyone of any specific values.
Rather, it should be understood that just because there is a disagreement does not mean there can’t be acceptance. As Baumgardt puts it, “Unity does not necessarily equate to uniformity.”
What, then, is the root of the antagonism? In my view, a significant part of it is attributable to fear. Each party fears that the other is in danger of letting go of one pole, to the detriment of women and indeed, to the detriment of all of society.
For their part, feminists are worried about the call to complementarity, not necessarily because they are opposed to the idea that both men and women bring some distinct and important gifts to human society, but because of the way that idea tends to work out in practice.
In fact, they fear it undermines collaboration, which in Latin means “working together, ” because it tends to promote both separation and practical inequality.
The common pursuit of excellence-or virtue-is also a type of collaboration. In fact, it is a key element of the classical definition of friendship.
Possibilities for collaboration
My larger goal for Notre Dame’s Contending Modernities Project is that it will broadly exemplify the collaboration spoken of so movingly by Pope Benedict XVI.
I look forward to collaboration among Catholics, Muslims, and secular thinkers, collaboration between men and women, and collaboration between papal feminists and secular feminists.
I anticipate collaboration in the pursuit of excellence and in furtherance of the common good. Most importantly, I hope for collaboration as we address our fears, build our trust, and cultivate our friendship.
Feminism and Catholicism therefore remain connected by a difficult but productive set of questions: how equality relates to difference, how nature relates to culture, how motherhood relates to public participation, and how collaboration can avoid becoming separation.
7 Women Who Changed the Catholic Church
tags: #feminism #and #catholicism