Is Alistair Begg a Calvinist?

Yes. Alistair Begg is widely identified as a Calvinist, or, more precisely, a Reformed Evangelical who holds a Reformed view of salvation. He is a Baptist who is influenced by Reformed theology, and he is described as unashamedly Reformed in his soteriology-the doctrine of salvation and damnation.

Begg’s theological associations, teaching ministry, and public statements place him within the Reformed tradition. He is an Alliance Council member, and the Alliance of Confessing Evangelicals is a broad coalition of evangelical pastors, scholars, and churchmen who hold the historic creeds and confessions of the Reformed faith and who proclaim biblical doctrine in order to foster a Reformed awakening in today’s Church.

What does “Calvinist” mean in Begg’s case?

To say that Begg is a Calvinist does not mean that he is a hyper-Calvinist or that he rejects evangelism. Calvinists in the SBC affirm the Baptist Faith and Message 2000, after all. Begg is a very conservative Calvinistic pastor with a national audience, one of the most gifted preachers in America, modeling how to go verse-by-verse, book-by-book through the Bible.

He’s committed to the inerrancy of Scripture and to a confessional orthodoxy. Begg is not only clear but interesting, engaging and frankly just about as good a speaker as one can find. Begg is not only greatly appreciated by a large so-called lay audience, including those in his own very large church, but is also respected among many scholars and theologians both inside and outside the Reformed community.

Begg is a Baptist who is influenced by Reformed theology. Begg is part of my regular diet of teachings, via the podcasts. He is solid, reformed, Calvinist, and a constant referrer to Puritan divines.

Begg’s Reformed theological identity

In widely circulated articles, books, audio/video messages (etc.), Begg speaks clearly, not only about what he believes and teaches but why he believes and teaches it. Concerning what is important for this article, Begg is a Reformed Evangelical.

In addition to what Begg has written and spoken, his association with (and in some cases leadership of) various Reformed ministries and organizations, Begg makes it clear that he is unashamedly Reformed in his soteriology (i.e., in his view of who can be saved and why).

From the Alliance of Confessing Evangelicals: Alistair Begg is an Alliance Council member and has been in pastoral ministry for 30 years; eight in Scotland following graduation from the London School of Theology, and 22 years at Parkside Church in suburban Cleveland, Ohio.

To me, the word Reformed is not used pejoratively but is simply a fair and accurate designation of a particular theological leaning or interpretation of Scripture related to salvation and damnation.

What Reformed soteriology teaches

The central issue is Begg’s doctrine of soteriology. Soteriologically, the Reformed view is about Reprobation and Election or unconditional salvation and unconditional damnation.

According to Alistair Begg, Mark Driscoll, J.I. Packer, Tim Keller, Wayne Grudem, Al Mohler, C.J. Mahaney, John MacArthur Jr., R.C. Sproul Sr., Francis Chan, David Platt and most all (if not all) mainstream Calvinists say that the Reformed doctrines of grace insists that:

  • Regeneration precedes and produces saving faith in Christ.
  • Only those unconditionally elected for salvation can and will be born again.
  • All of the elect will be regenerated.
  • God unconditionally elected to save some lost sinners and not all lost sinners.
  • Only the elect will (or even can) be saved.
  • All of the elect will be saved.
  • None of the non-elect can be saved.
  • Christ did not die for all the sins of all sinners and in fact He did not die for any of the sins of many sinners.
  • For the elect and only the elect Christ died for their sins.
  • That is, Christ only died savingly, redemptively or propitiously for the elect.
  • Only the elect are inwardly, effectively, efficaciously, or irresistibly called to saving faith in Christ.
  • To the non-elect, a Gospel proclamation is necessarily “waters on a ducks back” or totally ineffective.
  • All of the elect will persevere in faith and righteousness unto the end.
  • No one can be absolutely certain they are one of the elect until they have persevered in faith and holiness to the end.
  • Only after the final judgment is it possible to know for sure that the faith and righteousness someone is persevering in, is in fact the true faith and righteousness one need to persevere in (to the end) to be saved.

Election, reprobation, and the sovereignty of God

A theist says there is one all powerful, all knowing, present everywhere at once God, just as do all Reformed and non-Reformed Evangelical Christians. Fatalism is the belief that the future, especially where a person goes when they die, is predetermined and fixed by God, as is the case of all Reformed and Calvinist believers.

Theistic fatalism teaches that a person is from and to all eternity locked into salvation or damnation and cannot alter their destiny one way or the other. If a person does not embrace theistic fatalism he does not believe in the Reformed doctrine of grace.

According to Calvin, God by his eternal and immutable counsel determined those chosen or elected to salvation. The reprobate (non-elect for salvation) is doomed for destruction. The eternal and immutable counsel of God determines this destruction.

God passes by the non-elect, excluding them from his saving will or his decree of salvation. Reformed theology calls this “preterition.” It is defined as God’s sovereign passing by of the non-elect, thus excluding them from his decree of salvation.

This determination was made by the pleasure of God. The determined destruction of the reprobate is without respect to human worth. God is just (in those he gives life) and blameless (in those to whom he dooms to destruction). God’s judgment is beyond our understanding.

Calvinism, evangelism, and human responsibility

Some critics of Calvinism describe Calvinists as anti-evangelism, fatalistic, deniers of free-will, and blasphemers of God’s holiness. That characterization is rejected by Calvinists themselves. Calvinists were not heretical, but historically orthodox and textual.

They taught me that God was 100% sovereign and man was 100% responsible. They explained why Calvinists believed their doctrines and why Arminians did as well. I learned, at least, that both groups were trying to understand and explain Scripture.

The relationship between divine sovereignty and human responsibility is one of the defining features of the discussion. God is 100% sovereign and man is 100% responsible.

MacArthur’s Ashamed of the Gospel was earth-shattering for me. He was arguing contextually what I believed and helping me to clarify my views on biblical methodology. How could a Calvinist-a fatalist-argue so strongly for the church’s responsibility?

How Begg’s preaching is perceived

Begg is not only clear but interesting, engaging and frankly just about as good a speaker as one can find. He’s funny and entertaining. He’s really got the “gift of gab”. His forte is common-sensical truths.

He is so engaging and good when he is invited to speak to other groups of believers, that non-reformed churches seemed to overlook the fact that he is reformed in his soterology. While Begg may speak at conferences related to a non-Reformed movements, in non-Reformed churches, Begg could never be a pastor of a non-Reformed evangelical church, unless these churches became Reformed or Begg renounced his Reformed soteriology.

While Begg speaks to some non-Reformed audiences, he never teaches a Reformed soteriology when he does. I suspect that if he did, it would be his last invitation to a non-reformed conference or church. While his doctrine of salvation may be one of the most important of all subject matters to him, and it is, he does have other topics to talk about.

Begg’s sermons helped some listeners see historical-grammatical hermeneutics applied and appropriated in a manner that was faithful to Scripture. Yet, these men were all Calvinists. How could heretics be so textually sound?

Alistair Begg preaching from pulpit

Why some listeners do not immediately recognize him as Calvinist

Begg’s sermons are often focused on careful exposition of biblical texts rather than on repeatedly explaining the five points of Calvinism. He is a gifted expositor, and many of his messages emphasize the meaning of a particular passage, Christian living, repentance, faith, holiness, or the person and work of Christ.

Because of this, a listener may hear very few explicit references to Calvinism while still hearing a preacher whose underlying doctrine of salvation is Reformed. He is a constant referrer to Puritan divines, and his preaching reflects historical-grammatical hermeneutics and confessional Reformed theology.

If you know someone who is just awakening to reformed theology, or brand new to it, Begg’s your man. I recommend him to those who are new to Reformed Theology.

How Begg differs from non-Reformed Evangelicals

The two biggest camps of Evangelicalism are the non-Reformed and the Reformed camps. While I disagree with Begg on his doctrine of soteriolgy (i.e., the doctine of salvation and damnation) Begg strikes me as a very godly and gifted believer.

You do not have to agree with someone on everything to respect and appreciate what he says on some things. I do respect, agree with and appriciate much or what Begg teaches. I have heard him say very few things that I disagree with.

The principal distinction concerns who can be saved and why. Non-Reformed Evangelicals generally teach that salvation is available to all who believe in Christ, whereas Reformed theology teaches that salvation rests on God’s unconditional election and effective grace.

The non-Reformed view presented in the material

According to Chuck Smith Sr, J. Vernon McGee, Zane Hodges, Charles Stanley and (by definition and affirmation) all non-Reformed evangelicals (as well as all other mainstream non-Reformed Orthodox Evangelicals) agree that the Biblical doctrines of grace say that:

  • Saving faith in Christ always and immediately results in regeneration and any and all lost sinners can believe in Christ and be born again (Jn. 1: 10-13, 20: 30-31).
  • God desires all men to be saved and has determined that all can and will be saved on condition they believe in Jesus Christ (Jn. 3: 15-18, 1 Tim. 2: 3-4, Acts 16: 27-31).
  • Christ died savingly, redemptively, or propitiously for all the sins of all sinners (1 Jn. 2: 2, 2 Cor. 5: 14-15).
  • God calls all lost sinners to a saving faith in Jesus Christ through a Gospel proclamation and by believing the Gospel all lost sinners can and will be saved (Rom. 1: 16, 1 Cor. 15: 1-3).
  • All those who believe in Jesus Christ and are thus saved (regenerated and justified) are called to live a life to please, honor, and glorify the Lord.
  • Living this life, although possible for and expected of the believer, is not automatic or inevitable for the believer (Rom. 12: 1-2, Eph. 4: 1-3, 2 Pet. 1: 1-10).

Calvinism and hyper-Calvinism

Begg’s Calvinism should not automatically be equated with hyper-Calvinism. I am still against Hyper-Calvinism today, but so is every other Southern Baptist Calvinist I know. Hyper-Calvinism is not the Calvinism that primarily exists within the SBC.

Calvinists in the SBC affirm the Baptist Faith and Message 2000, after all. Many of the founders of the Southern Baptist Convention were 5-point Calvinists.

Let’s not put words in their mouths. Instead, let us seek to understand their position before we condemn them. Let’s converse and debate back and forth while realizing that this is a debate between brothers, not a debate between Southern Baptists and heretics.

Begg’s ministry and background

Alistair Begg is the Bible teacher on Truth For Life, a daily and weekend program that brings the exposition of Scripture to a global audience through radio, podcast, and a wide range of digital and streaming platforms.

Since its launch in 1995, Truth For Life has featured teaching drawn from Alistair’s decades of faithful preaching at Parkside Church, where he served as senior pastor from 1983 until 2025. Today, Alistair is actively engaged with Truth For Life and speaks frequently at conferences throughout the United States and around the world, where he encourages pastors, theology students, and believers and proclaims the Gospel to those who have yet to come to faith in Jesus Christ.

Alistair began in pastoral ministry in 1975 after graduating from the London School of Theology. Before joining Parkside Church, he served for eight years in Scotland, ministering at Charlotte Chapel in Edinburgh and Hamilton Baptist Church.

Alistair and his wife, Susan, have been married since 1975. They have three grown children and nine grandchildren.

He has written several books and is heard daily across the nation on the radio program, Truth for Life. He is the author of several books, including Name Above All Names, Pray Big, and Brave by Faith.

His books have been translated into many languages and are read by a global audience.

The 2023-2024 controversy and its relation to his theology

A recent controversy surrounding Begg’s advice about attending a transgender wedding does not change the answer to the question of whether he is a Calvinist. The disagreement concerned the application of Christian convictions, conscience, compassion, and public identification with a wedding ceremony, rather than whether Begg holds Reformed soteriology.

During a September 2023 episode of the Truth for Life podcast, Pastor Begg recounted a time he counseled a Christian grandmother to attend her grandson’s wedding to a transgender woman (a biological male living as a woman)-and to bring the couple a gift.

In Pastor Begg’s view, the grandmother’s attendance would present her with the opportunity to show Christian love to her grandson and his transgendered partner, and it would thusly create an opportunity to witness Christ to them in the future.

“We’re going to have to take that risk a lot more if we want to build bridges into the hearts and lives of those who don’t understand Jesus and don’t understand that he is a King,” Begg shared.

Some Christians argued that this counsel compromised biblical convictions. Others, including Russell Moore, treated it as a question involving conscience and the distinction between attending a wedding and endorsing the marriage itself.

Arguments that criticized Begg’s counsel

Upon learning of Pastor Begg’s counsel to the grandmother, I initially counted it as a terrible misstep of which he’d surely repent when shown his error.

Then I learned that Begg’s team had doubled down on his behalf in response to AFR’s earnest attempts to ask him to retract his counsel. Then I watched Begg’s sermon “Compassion vs. Condemnation”, which he delivered before his congregation on January 28, 2024.

Pastor Begg essentially concluded his sermon by acknowledging that his counsel to the grandmother was merely an opinion born of his emotions, rather than Christian convictions.

“I think as long as you understand that my response to one grandmother, whom I have never met, was not in any way a blanket recommendation to all Christians to attend LGBTQ weddings. If I was misguided in any way, it was that I allowed my ‘grandfather hat’ to take over. It was my personal opinion, as I sensed what was best as I learned about the individual and specific situation.”

Arguments defending Begg’s counsel

Russell Moore wrote that Begg was not trying to compromise or to condemn. He was trying to hold in tension two very biblical truths; he was trying to avoid conforming to the pattern of this world when it comes to obeying God.

He was also trying to avoid being the kind of person who says that it’s beneath one’s purity to “eat with tax collectors and sinners” (Mark 2:16), the very charge that the very religious made of the Lord Jesus himself.

Might Begg be drawing the line in the wrong place-too much in the direction of showing grace? Sure. Might I be drawing it in the wrong place-too much in the direction of maintaining truth? Again, yes. He risks confusing people. I risk hurting people.

That’s why I think we both attempt to sort these out with fear and trembling and a willingness to be corrected.

Why the controversy does not make Begg non-Calvinist

The controversy involved Begg’s pastoral judgment in a particular cultural situation. It did not amount to a renunciation of Reformed soteriology, nor did it establish that he had adopted a non-Reformed doctrine of salvation.

Begg’s position on election, regeneration, saving faith, the extent of Christ’s atonement, and the relationship between divine sovereignty and human responsibility is the relevant evidence for classifying his soteriology. His theological identity remains Reformed.

While there are many things that Begg believes and teaches unrelated to Reformed soteriology that I (along with many other non-Reformed Evangelicals) wholeheartedly agree with, his doctrine of salvation is still one of the most important distinctions between him and non-Reformed Evangelicals.

Is Alistair Begg a five-point Calvinist?

Begg is commonly described as a Calvinist and a Reformed Evangelical. The available descriptions identify him with the Reformed doctrines of grace and with organizations committed to Reformed confessional theology.

Some discussions describe him simply as “Reformed” or “Calvinist,” while others use the broader expression “influenced by Reformed theology.” The precise label may depend on how strictly one defines “five-point Calvinist,” but the overall answer remains the same: Begg belongs to the Reformed theological camp, especially in his doctrine of salvation.

He’s a better man than I. I wouldn’t say he’s a Calvinist; maybe a Spurgeonist. Yet, the more consistent descriptions identify Begg as solid, reformed, and Calvinist.

How to understand Begg’s theological profile

The most accurate short description is that Alistair Begg is a Baptist, conservative, Reformed Evangelical pastor and Bible teacher. His preaching is strongly expositional, his theology is confessionally orthodox, and his doctrine of salvation is Reformed.

He is not best classified as a non-Reformed Evangelical simply because he speaks at non-Reformed conferences, addresses mixed audiences, or teaches subjects other than soteriology. While Begg speaks to some non-Reformed audiences, he never teaches a Reformed soteriology when he does.

He can be appreciated for his biblical exposition, clarity, humor, pastoral warmth, and commitment to Scripture even by Christians who reject Calvinism. You do not have to agree with someone on everything to respect and appreciate what he says on some things.

Therefore, the direct answer is yes: Alistair Begg is a Calvinist in the historic Reformed sense, particularly regarding his doctrine of salvation, while remaining a Baptist in church tradition and practice.

tags: #is #alistair #begg #a #calvinist