Mount Calvary is a walkable Wisconsin community in the area known as “The Holy Land,” recognized for its scenic areas, open spaces, and abundance of natural resources. According to US Census Data, there are 87 residents in Mount Calvary, while the census of 2010 recorded 762 people, 201 households, and 151 families residing in the village.
Nextdoor Neighbors describe Mount Calvary as a good neighborhood to live in, with friendly residents, a convenient location, neighbors, stores, and yards among its top advantages. Mount Calvary is also considered a walkable neighborhood by Nextdoor Neighbors.
What Mount Calvary is like
Mount Calvary was originally part of the Town of Marshfield, the area known as “The Holy Land”, which boasts of scenic areas, open spaces, and an abundance of natural resources. The community combines a small-town setting with local stores, residential yards, nearby outdoor areas, and a strong historical connection to Catholic settlement and education.
The top reasons Nextdoor Neighbors love Mount Calvary are: friendly, location, neighbors, stores, and yards. These qualities reflect the community’s residential character and the importance of both local relationships and convenient surroundings.
Things to do for fun in Mount Calvary
Nextdoor Neighbors in Mount Calvary rate their top interests as home improvement & diy, walking, dogs, gardening & landscape, books, green bay packers, hiking & trails, local & regional issues, cats, and road trips.
- Home improvement and DIY projects
- Walking
- Spending time with dogs
- Gardening and landscape activities
- Reading books
- Following the Green Bay Packers
- Hiking and exploring trails
- Discussing local and regional issues
- Spending time with cats
- Taking road trips
Mount Calvary is considered a walkable neighborhood by Nextdoor Neighbors. Walking, gardening, hiking, and trails provide ways to enjoy the area’s open spaces and natural surroundings, while home projects and landscape work fit the community’s residential setting.

History of Mount Calvary
The Holy Land area was first settled in 1841. Mount Calvary emerged in the Holy Land when Mount Calvary's location was chosen by missionary Casper Rehrl.
Rehrl selected the large hill because of its excellent view and he placed a wood cross. Starting in 1846, settlers started building houses at the base of the hill.
The first religious community
Rehrl held the community's first mass circa 1849 at the home of John Dietzen. Bishop John Henni confirmed the first child from Mount Calvary at the St. John the Baptist Church in nearby Johnsburg (it was the only church in the region).
A parish was established in Mount Calvary by Rehrl on February 2, 1849. Construction of the church began the following day.
A school was established by the church and it quickly had five or six students. The early parish and school helped establish Mount Calvary as a religious and educational center within the surrounding settlement.
Growth of local services and transportation
The community's first general store was built in 1851-1852. A railroad was established in the 1850's and 1860's.
It connected Sheboygan to Fond du lac. Trains ran twice daily through nearby Calvary Station.
Two priests arrived on October 15th, 1856 to establish a monastery, which later became St. Lawrence Seminary High School. A post office was built in November 1877, for which Anthony Rothgery was named the first postmaster.

Population and incorporation
By 1900, the town of Marshfield area had reached a population of 1,992. That included the Villages of St. Cloud and Mt. Calvary.
In 1909, the Village of St. Cloud was incorporated. In 1962, the Village of Mt. Calvary incorporated, with a village population of 942 residents.
As of the census of 2010, there were 762 people, 201 households, and 151 families residing in the village.
| Population detail | Information |
|---|---|
| Town of Marshfield area by 1900 | 1,992 |
| Village population at incorporation in 1962 | 942 residents |
| Village population in the 2010 census | 762 people |
| Households in the 2010 census | 201 households |
| Families in the 2010 census | 151 families |
| US Census Data | 87 residents |
Why residents value Mount Calvary
The top reasons Nextdoor Neighbors love Mount Calvary are: friendly, location, neighbors, stores, and yards. The community’s appeal is therefore connected to its social atmosphere, local accessibility, residential surroundings, and small-community character.
Its location in the Holy Land area also places Mount Calvary within a setting shaped by scenic areas, open spaces, and an abundance of natural resources. For residents who enjoy walking, gardening, hiking, home improvement, and local activities, these characteristics help define everyday life in the community.