In Catholic teaching, prudence is the virtue that disposes practical reason to discern our true good in every circumstance and to choose the right means of achieving it (Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1806). Prudence helps a person think through things and act in ways that are right, good, and pleasing to God.
Prudence tells us what is good, when to do it, and how to do it. It helps us know and choose the right ways to reach a good end or goal, while searching for, knowing, and doing God’s will.
What prudence means in Catholic teaching
Prudence is one of the four Cardinal Virtues first defined by Plato and refined by Aristotle. The other three cardinal virtues are justice, fortitude, and temperance. The word “cardo” means “hinge,” so the cardinal virtues are the virtues on which all the other others hinge or turn.
The ancient Greeks valued these virtues for secular as well as idealistic reasons. But Catholic teaching says Grace enhances and even perfects these virtues. Prudence is considered the queen of virtues, leading them through good reasoning.
The word prudence comes from the Latin prudentia, contracted from providentia, meaning seeing ahead. Aristotle’s “recta ratio agibilium” has the merits of brevity and inclusiveness. Father Rickaby aptly renders it as “right reason applied to practice”.
A fuller description and one more serviceable is this: an intellectual habit enabling us to see in any given juncture of human affairs what is virtuous and what is not, and how to come at the one and avoid the other.
In common usage, prudence has taken on an aura of “Does this thing to be undertaken have a good chance of succeeding?” This is a far cry from how St. Thomas Aquinas’ defines prudence: “right reason in action.”
Merriam-Webster says prudence is: the ability to govern and discipline oneself by the use of reason; sagacity or shrewdness in the management of affairs; skill and good judgment in the use of resources.
Prudence and the good
The thing that is missing from the secular definitions is attention to the Good. This is something that was integral to the earlier Greek thought as shown throughout the work of Plato and Aristotle. And it remains so for Christians such as St. Augustine and St. Thomas Aquinas.
The ability to govern and discipline oneself toward goodness by the use of reason; sagacity or shrewdness in the management of affairs so that they lead to good ends; skill and good judgment in the right and proper use of resources.
These are small changes in wording perhaps, but necessary in an age of self-centered self-indulgence. Too often encouragement “to do good” is heard as advocating a course of self-sacrifice, which is anathema in a selfish age.
As Catholics we believe that there is but one source of goodness. As such, prudence with goodness as its object must also be blessed by God. Godly prudence leads us not merely to doing well, but closer to God.
Prudence helps us to understand our end-to love God and neighbor and to be a saint. Prudence helps us discern what will lead us to holiness.
Prudence as an intellectual and moral virtue
Prudence is both an intellectual and a moral virtue. It qualifies immediately the intellect and not the will, yet it is nevertheless rightly styled a moral virtue.
Its function is to point out which course of action is to be taken in any round of concrete circumstances. It indicates which, here and now, is the golden mean wherein the essence of all virtue lies.
It has nothing to do with directly willing the good it discerns. That is done by the particular moral virtue within whose province it falls.
Prudence, therefore, has a directive capacity with regard to the other virtues. It lights the way and measures the arena for their exercise. The insight it confers makes one distinguish successfully between their mere semblance and their reality.
It must preside over the eliciting of all acts proper to any one of them at least if they be taken in their formal sense. Thus, without prudence bravery becomes foolhardiness; mercy sinks into weakness, and temperance into fanaticism.
But it must not be forgotten that prudence is a virtue adequately distinct from the others, and not simply a condition attendant upon their operation. Its office is to determine for each in practice those circumstances of time, place, manner, etc. which should be observed, and which the Scholastics comprise under the term medium rationis.
| Aspect | Role of prudence |
|---|---|
| Intellect | It determines what should be done in concrete circumstances. |
| Moral life | It directs the exercise of the other virtues. |
| Action | It identifies the right means to a good end. |
| Spiritual life | It helps choices conform to God’s will. |
Why prudence is called the charioteer of the virtues
These examples demonstrate why Prudence has been considered the virtue that leads and drives the rest. As the “Catechism of the Catholic Church” says, “It is called auriga virtutum (the charioteer of the virtues); it guides the other virtues by setting rule and measure. It is prudence that immediately guides the judgment of conscience.”
Prudence requires us to consider where our actions-including our thoughts and wishes-will lead. It is not enough to think being careful is the equivalent of prudence; our caution must be formed with an eye to God.
Pagan prudence looks to the benefit of the practitioner first, his family or clan second, his village or town third, his country next, and so on. Christian prudence is formed with an eye to conformity God’s will.
The three acts of prudence
According to St. Thomas, it is the function of prudence to do three things: to take counsel, i.e. to cast about for the means suited in the particular case under consideration to reach the end of any one moral virtue; to judge soundly of the fitness of the means suggested; and, finally, to command their employment.
In his “Summa Theologiae,” Saint Thomas Aquinas explains three important actions related to prudence: seeking counsel, judging, and commanding.
- Seeking counsel: asking the right questions and looking for the means suited to the situation.
- Judging: finding the right answers to those questions and judging whether the proposed means are suitable.
- Commanding: applying what has been learned to the action itself.
If these are to be done well they necessarily exclude remissness and lack of concern; they demand the use of such diligence and care that the resultant act can be described as prudent, in spite of whatever speculative error may have been at the bottom of the process.
The integral parts of prudence
The integral parts of Prudence are those parts of the virtue which are necessary for the virtue to be exercised perfectly. Analogous to the foundation, walls and roof of a house, without them the house (one’s action) will be shaky, if not dilapidated.
They, therefore, concern the things the prudent person must know, in order to judge rightly, as well as the things to be concerned with in judging and putting the decision into action.
The exercise of the virtue is not perfect without all of Prudence’s integral parts. An imperfect act of virtue, therefore, is imprudent, even if the moral object (the thing done) and the intention of the will is good.
Memory
We learn a lot from things that have happened in the past. For example, if I burned my hand after touching a hot stove. From that experience, I learned that it hurts to touch a hot stove. So next time I will be more careful and not touch it.
The knowledge of past events is stored in our memory. You can use your experiences to help you make prudent choices.
Understanding
You must know what is right and wrong before you can choose what is right. Understanding helps you grasp the knowledge of good and evil.
Studying the Bible and Church teaching are great ways to understand right from wrong.
Docility
People are not born knowing everything. We must be taught. Docility is the willingness to be taught.
If someone is docile, he or she is ready to “soak up” knowledge and is always willing and ready to learn. You can work on docility by listening to your teachers and parents, taking corrections well, or listening to and thinking about someone else’s ideas.
Foresight
Foresight is having a view of the future and thinking ahead. For example, if your mom asked you to pack your bag for a weekend trip, it would be good to check the weather so you can pack appropriately.
This is an example of foresight. When making decisions, it is important to think about the consequences of those decisions. Consider what might happen in the future if you act a certain way now.
Circumspection
Circumspection is looking at all the facts and circumstances around a situation and thinking about them carefully when deciding what needs to be done.
It is important to take time to pray about and to think things through before acting.
Caution
Caution helps you avoid evil, and helps you to watch out for things that are keeping you from doing good. God does not just want you to avoid doing bad things. God also wants you to do good things.
Practicing caution can help you realize if you are not doing something you should be doing.
Prudence, perfectionism, and trust in God
Perfectionism often reveals a lack of prudence. Perfectionism takes the form of a need for control and flawlessness.
Imperfection becomes unacceptable, blinding perfectionists of our need for and reliance on God. Perfectionism, in this sense, is distinct from Gospel perfection, which calls for us to orient our will to God’s and to reach our heavenly perfection as saints.
Perfectionism distorted my vision through hypercriticism, leading to pride. It was the shadow side to my diligence, care, love of beauty, and attention to detail.
But perfectionism is a barrier to virtue. It prevents us from seeing, choosing, and acting well.
“Cultivating virtue in the desert” doesn’t mean perfecting every character flaw or seeing the attainment of virtue as a success to achieve. I love the idea of “cultivating,” because in my own work, I see myself as a cultivator.
I tend to the fields on earth so that I can reach God in Heaven. I try to plant new seeds of creativity, rooted in Christ, and restore our creative imagination. I try to create space for other makers to flourish.
How to practice prudence
Discover wisdom in good counsel
Aquinas says that counsel is a gift of prudence. Counsel requires us to ask good questions related to the decision we are trying to make. It also requires us to listen well for the answer.
In order to seek counsel, we first need to acknowledge our mistakes and accept them as part of our humanity. Through this acceptance, we grow in humility and embrace our capacity to learn from mistakes.
Humility helps us receive truth and allows us to discern and seek out good counsel from someone, such as a good spiritual director. Receiving wise counsel also teaches us how to become wise ourselves.
Discern and judge well
In order to discern and judge well, we need to desire the true good. We need to desire God’s will for us and know that his will fulfills the deepest longings in our heart for happiness.
Finally, when we seek answers to our questions, we need to be guided by truth.
Be decisive and act
Decisiveness shouldn’t be confused with haste. In my perfectionism, I am often indecisive, not for lack of being able to understand the facts and judge rightly, but because of a fear of making the wrong choice.
This fear comes from a lack of trust in God. Since prudence is reason and action, it is closely related to practical wisdom-the knowledge we need to make good and decisive choices that reflect our love of God.
We don’t often think that the way we make decisions can be grounds for cultivating virtue, but the virtue of prudence is all about choosing well and acting rightly.
Prudence in everyday decisions
God gives us free will so we can choose to do what is good. Prudence tells us what is good, when to do it, and how to do it.
For example, getting an A on your next test is a good goal but cheating would be a bad way to get it. Instead, studying would be the right way to reach your goal of getting an A.
Practicing prudence requires thoughtful examination of circumstances and thinking about where different choices might lead. Christian prudence requires us to extend the consideration to which choice or choices lead us closer to God, closer to walking in God’s will.
Our work presents so many opportunities to make choices, and it helps to reflect on them later: Did my choice contribute to my flourishing? How did my choice draw me closer to God?
Reflections like these root our decisions in the will of God and cultivate virtue that will someday bear fruit through our labor.
Prudence and stewardship
In my own life, this has involved periodically stopping to examine (and re-examine) where my choices are leading me. I grew up in a family where several different years featured a certain amount of financial insecurity.
This left me with a propensity to be both frugal and careful about making financial plans and decisions. Planning good stewardship with the Church and different charities should be a natural extension of frugality and good financial planning.
But as it turns out, this takes me some extra effort and discipline.
Prudence and avoiding occasions of sin
In a similar way, ordinary prudence would lead someone away from walking through rough areas of town alone at night. But Godly prudence echoes the sentence from the Act of Contrition.
We promise to avoid near occasions of sin. We should also be prudent in our conversations, our web browsing, our companions, and our daily activities.
Acquired and infused prudence
Besides the prudence which is the fruit of training and experience, and is developed into a stable habit by repeated acts, there is another sort termed “infused”. This is directly bestowed by God’s bounty.
It is inseparable from the condition of supernatural charity and so is to be found only in those who are in the state of grace. Its scope of course is to make provision of what is necessary for eternal salvation.
Although acquired prudence considered as a principle of operation is quite compatible with sin in the agent, still it is well to note that vice obscures or at times utterly beclouds its judgment.
Thus it is true that prudence and the other moral virtues are mutually interdependent.
False prudence and imprudence
Readiness in finding out and ability in adapting means to an end does not always imply prudence. If the end happens to be a vicious one, a certain adroitness or sagacity may be exhibited in its pursuit.
This, however, according to St. Thomas, will only deserve to be called false prudence and is identical with that referred to in Rom., viii, 6, “the wisdom of the flesh is death”.
Imprudence is the lack or absence of prudence. Imprudence in so far as it implies a want of obligatory prudence and not a mere gap in practical mentality is a sin, not however always necessarily distinct from the special wicked indulgence which it happens to accompany.
If it proceed to the length of formal scorn of the Divine utterances on the point, it will be a mortal sin.
Precipitation
Precipitation has nothing to do with the weather. Precipitation is when someone acts too quickly and does not think before acting.
Sometimes this happens when you act on how you feel instead of thinking about what should be done.
Thoughtlessness
Thoughtlessness is when a person is careless and does not think about those things which can lead to a prudent act.
This vice ignores many of the parts of prudence discussed above, like foresight and circumspection.
Inconstancy
Inconstancy is when someone stops or withdrawals from completing a good and prudent action.
Steps to making a prudent decision
- Deliberate: Gather any information you need to make a good decision. This may include seeing what Jesus teaches about your situation by looking at the Bible and Church teachings. You can seek good counsel, which means to ask a trusted adult for advice.
- Make a good judgment: After you deliberate, first pray. Ask God for help. Think through the information and advice you received. Consider different decisions you could make and their consequences.
- Action: Now it is time to actually do the right thing. You have already prayed and thought about it, so it is time to act and do what is good.
Practical habits for growing in prudence
- Find a person you think is wise and ask them for advice on how to make good decisions.
- Always think before you speak or act. Ask yourself if what you are about to say or do is right and good.
- Learn from other people’s decisions. Write down some decisions you see people making. Discuss with an adult negative and positive consequences that can happen when someone makes good decisions and bad decisions.
- Find a Bible verse about prudence or wisdom and memorize it.
- Before making any decision, pray to God and ask for help.
A prayer for prudence
Dear Lord, please help me to know what is right. Guide me on when and how to do what is good. Teach me to think before I act. You are my Rock and I trust you will lead me to make decisions that are pleasing to you. Amen

tags: #prudence #catholic #definition