Former Seventh-day Adventist Experiences, Beliefs, and Reasons for Leaving

Former Seventh-day Adventists describe leaving the church as a deeply personal process involving beliefs, family relationships, community ties, identity, and expectations about salvation. Some leave after a long period of Bible study and theological questioning, while others are pushed away by strict social rules, exclusion, institutional culture, or the treatment of LGBTQ people.

Leaving Adventism does not always mean leaving Christianity. Some former members become progressive Christians, join other denominations, explore another religious tradition, or remain spiritually open without belonging to a church. Others identify as agnostic or atheist. Across these experiences, a common theme is the difficulty of separating from a worldview that has shaped education, family life, friendships, worship, moral decisions, and the understanding of God.

Why leaving the Seventh-day Adventist Church can be difficult

The SDA Church, like many high-demand religious groups, offers a comprehensive worldview that influences every aspect of life-from dietary choices and educational paths to social interactions and personal values. For many, it's not just about stepping away from a religious institution but also about disentangling from deeply ingrained beliefs, community ties, and personal identities that have been shaped over years.

Departing from such an environment can lead to feelings of confusion, guilt, anxiety, and isolation. You might find yourself questioning long-held beliefs, grappling with fears instilled by teachings about end times or divine judgment, and mourning the loss of community and identity. It's essential to recognize that these reactions are valid and common among those who have left high-control religious settings.

Leaving a faith community can be akin to grieving a loss. The process of deconstruction-critically examining and often dismantling one's belief system-is a significant step toward healing and self-discovery.

How former Adventists describe their experiences

Growing up inside an Adventist environment

Grant Wareham grew up attending the Kettering Seventh-day Adventist Church, and during an evangelistic series in Dayton, Ohio, he once served as a Bible worker. Three or four GYC (Generation. Youth. Christ.) conventions line his past travels. “My parents tended to be more toward the conservative side,” he told Spectrum. “Alcohol was of course a big no-no, and Sabbath was very strict.”

Wareham was homeschooled, and outside of rehearsal for a youth orchestra and music groups at his church, he didn’t have much unstructured time to socialize with his peers as he grew up. “I didn’t really have many friends my age. I’ve taken the Buzzfeed ‘How Strict Were Your Parents?’ quizzes just for the heck of it, and half of the questions didn’t even apply to me because it was like, ‘When was your curfew?’ Well, I didn’t go anywhere, so I didn’t have one.”

Pia Irizarry is a fifth-generation Adventist from her father’s side. Her mother converted from Catholicism when she met Irizarry’s father. Growing up, the contrast between her father’s side of the family (which Irizarry described as “ultra-conservative”) and her mother’s (not “ultra-conservative”) was striking.

“I was homeschooled and vegan, which makes you really weird,” she said half-jokingly. “My parents are the kind that, it doesn’t matter, rain or shine or sickness or health or whatever, you’ll always go to church on Saturdays.” She spent most of her childhood in the suburbs of Chicago, deeply embedded within the Hispanic Adventist community her parents were a part of.

“I never thought too much about it because it was just so second nature,” she said. Going to church on Saturday and praying before meals was another part of her DNA.

Adventist schools, camps, and universities

One former Adventist attended Seventh-day Adventist schools from kindergarten to 8th grade. She enjoyed friendships with many of her schoolmates and had some great and caring teachers, but she did tend to get into trouble with her propensity to question authority and disrupt class by talking too much.

In the summers she went to SDA camp at Mt. Aetna in Hagerstown, MD every year from 7 to 15 years old. Mt. Aetna was my favorite place on earth growing up. I understand now that it was a respite and haven from ongoing conflict at home. I will always cherish those fun and carefree times in my childhood.

In addition to SDA school and summer camp, she attended SDA church weekly growing up. During her most formative years (12-18), she had a really wonderful youth leader. He was one of those people who the kids knew genuinely cared and didn’t judge us regardless of what challenges we were going through in our teen years.

She later attended Andrews University. “I loved my time there, other than the cold climate from being located in Michigan!” Her living situation was peaceful for the first time in her life, there were hot prepared meals always available, and it was easy for her to make other SDA friends.

Andrews University has a campus church called Pioneer Memorial. The pastor there at the time was Dwight Nelson. He gave the impression that his spiritual life was authentic and his love for people was genuine. She had many great professors and deans, and the university was very active in outreach in a local impoverished city, Benton Harbor, hosting all sorts of programs for the residents there.

Grant Wareham enrolled at Rice University, a secular institution, after turning 18. He had a plan. He’d attend the Adventist church on Saturdays and use his skills to earn money at “work” church on Sundays. Soon though, “I found myself rolling my eyes at most of what I was doing and seeing on Saturdays and enjoying what I was seeing on Sundays,” he said.

The contrast between Adventist institutions and local churches

One former member came home from Andrews, excited about the experience she had there with the worship programs, service opportunities, and sense of community. She thought to herself that there was no reason similar outreach programs couldn’t be done to help impoverished residents in DC as were being done for those in Benton Harbor.

She contacted an SDA church in DC to see if they had any community outreach programs. They didn’t, so she felt inspired to try to start one. She assembled information packets for around 30 nearby churches inviting them to join in for a widespread community outreach effort.

After all of our effort and preparation, we were really disheartened when not a single one of the 30 churches we contacted responded to the packets we sent out. At the DC host church, only one elder who I assume was assigned to supervise our activity there, participated in the outreach to their local neighbors. He didn’t participate for very long.

From my own home church, only my youth leader and eventually my mother volunteered with us. When we did go into the local neighborhood to offer to pray with people, many of the neighbors told us they’d lived next to that church for years and we were the first people to ever reach out to them.

When the same former member moved to Virginia, she tried the only SDA church in the city where she lived. Unfortunately there weren’t any outreach or young adult programs in place. The church had an older population, and it was very common for members of the congregation to sleep through the Divine service.

I quickly began to feel like I was just going to church to “swipe my SDA card,” so to speak. I trailed off of going to church for the first time in my life. I felt guilty for not attending regularly but felt worse and more frustrated when I did go.

Questioning the Adventist worldview

Grant Wareham began to hear ideas in other denominations that challenged the worldview that had insulated him for so long. “If I heard something I thought I disagreed [with], I needed to be able to quantify to myself why I disagreed with it without mental gymnastics, or I had to change my opinion,” Wareham explained.

This simple, unassuming method teed off a “long, slow process” in which his most cherished tenets were challenged. “Suddenly, I couldn’t justify to myself why I believed what I believed.”

It wasn’t until his sophomore year of college that Wareham thought to himself that perhaps the earth is more than 6,000 years old. Or maybe other denominations offer good things, too.

“The whole Adventist mindset of ‘this is the church’ was so ingrained into me that it was a long process to admit that this wasn’t something that I felt I identified with.”

Ann S. describes deconstruction as the process of questioning inherited religious beliefs. Her father intensely studied doctrine and questioned Adventist theology, such as the “investigative judgment” and the “sanctuary doctrine.” In return, she remembers that “he’d be called a heretic.” But while her father was questioning, he also encouraged his children to decide for themselves what they believed.

Ann went to an Adventist academy for high school and pursued higher education at an Adventist university. She eventually became a music teacher and worked for several Adventist schools. Later, Ann began to teach in public schools-“the real world,” she called it.

“When I was out in the working world outside of Adventism, I discovered how much of a bubble I had been raised in and that I’d put myself in, having only gone to Adventist university and only worked in Adventist spaces.”

Following in her father’s footsteps, she started studying. “I got to the point where I was criticizing every sermon I listened to,” she said. “I realized that a lot of what I had grown up believing wasn’t true. So, I felt I had to leave the bubble.”

Doctrinal reasons former Adventists give for leaving

The reasons why people leave the Adventist church are as diverse as the church itself. Some former members describe a gradual loss of confidence in Adventist theology, while others identify one particular teaching as the point at which they could no longer remain.

The investigative judgment

The doctrine of the Investigative Judgement is one of the core pillars and founding teachings of the Seventh-day Adventist Church. This doctrine claims that in 1844, Christ entered the Most Holy Place of the heavenly sanctuary to begin a process of reviewing the lives of believers, a sort of divine audit to determine who will be saved.

This teaching was developed to account for the failed prophecy of William Miller, who predicted Christ’s return in 1844. When that return did not occur, early Adventists, under the prophetic guidance of Ellen G. White, reinterpreted the event as a transition in Christ’s heavenly ministry from the Holy Place into the Most Holy Place.

Ronald N. Emanuel writes that he accepted this worldview because it was all he knew. But when he began studying the Scriptures more directly, particularly the epistle to the Hebrews, he encountered a problem.

Hebrews 9:12 says explicitly that Christ entered into the Most Holy Place once for all, having obtained eternal redemption. There is no indication that He waited 1,800 years to begin this work; rather, the cross itself marked the decisive moment of atonement, and His resurrection and ascension confirmed its completion.

After offering a single, “once-for-all” sacrifice for sins, Christ sat down at the right hand of God (Hebrews 10:12-14). That sitting down signifies finality, not continuation of his sacrifice.

The idea that Christ’s atoning work remained incomplete until 1844 not only lacks biblical support, but it also undermines the sufficiency and finished nature of His sacrifice. The practical consequence of this doctrine is equally troubling. It introduces uncertainty and anxiety.

Adventists are left wondering whether their names will survive the investigative process, whether their past sins might rise against them in judgement. This was my experience. I affirmed justification by faith with my lips, but in my heart, I felt I was always under review.

Sabbath observance

The main practice that SDA’s are known for is keeping the Jewish, or 7th day Sabbath, hence the name Seventh-day Adventist. The way people choose to observe the Sabbath varies from family to family.

Some don’t believe in frequenting businesses on Sabbath because it requires other people to work, while others don’t mind. A family I grew up around wouldn’t allow their children to play on the playground on Sabbath.

I wasn’t allowed to swim in a swimming pool on Sabbath “because it’s man made,” but if we were at the beach then it was fine to swim in the ocean because it’s a natural body of water. There are lots of peculiar rules and practices within the denomination.

For some former Adventists, the Sabbath remains one of the most meaningful parts of their former religious life. Even though I’m not SDA anymore, I do still like the concept of observing a weekly day of rest. I look forward to it coming and enjoy the break from work.

My husband and I typically use it as designated family time. We spend time outdoors, catch up on rest, etc. Everyone needs rest. I enjoy Sabbath, but as with sex or anything else intended to be enjoyable, I think strict religious practices spoil it.

Ronald Emanuel describes a different theological concern. Perhaps the most cherished doctrine in Adventism is the observance of the seventh-day Sabbath. It is more than a day of rest; it is viewed as the seal of God, the identifying mark of the true remnant, and a sign of faithful obedience in the end times.

Conversely, Sunday observance is portrayed as the mark of the beast, a dangerous deception. And anyone who worships on Sunday will lose their salvation, no matter how sincere and faithful they were to Christ.

In Colossians 2:16-17, the apostle Paul writes, “Let no one pass judgement on you in questions of food and drink, or with regard to a festival or a new moon or a Sabbath. These are a shadow of the things to come, but the substance belongs to Christ.”

In Romans 14:5, Paul allows for freedom in the observance of days: “One person esteems one day as better than another, while another esteems all days alike. Each one should be fully convinced in his own mind.”

More importantly, I came to understand that Christ is our true Sabbath rest (Hebrews 4:9-10). He is the One in whom we cease from our labors, trusting not in our observance but in His perfect obedience on our behalf.

Ellen G. White and prophetic authority

Madlyn Albertson said that the Adventist church’s focus on Ellen G. White as a prophet has pushed her away. In 2020, Albertson researched White’s writings and the basis of their status within the Adventist church. What she found left her feeling quite betrayed.

“It’s not about our theology from the Bible,” she said. The disconnect between what she discovered while reading about White and what the church believes is difficult for her to qualify. “Once you take her out of the picture . there’s not a whole lot left.”

Michael Bamberg agrees. “I really don’t know how anybody can believe in Ellen White. There’s, in my opinion, not very good witness reports of her miracles. I think she’s a severe persona anyway, and that doesn’t tend to gain much traction among young people,” Bamberg said.

“She’s too theologically unique to disbelieve in and still call yourself an Adventist.”

Ellen G. White’s role in the Seventh-day Adventist Church is both foundational and problematic. Though the denomination claims she is a “lesser light” leading to the “greater light” of Scripture, in practice, her writings function as the authoritative lens through which all Scripture is interpreted.

Her visions are used to confirm doctrine, explain prophecy, and settle theological disputes. For many years, former Adventists revered her writings but later concluded that her authority had displaced that of Scripture.

One former Adventist writes that Ellen Gould White is the most critical author and founding pioneer of the Seventh-day Adventist Church. “It is an understatement to say that, Adventism wouldn’t exist without the writings and teachings of Ellen G. White.”

The Seventh-day Adventist Church utilizes the term “spirit of prophecy” to refer to Ellen White’s writings. They believe Jesus is speaking through Ellen White with prophetic authority no differently than through the prophets of scripture.

Many Adventists claim that their beliefs are only based on the Bible and provide proof texts to show how they are Sola Scriptura. However, it’s crucial to encourage critical thinking and independent interpretation in religious studies.

Challenging this belief can be empowering, as it allows for the development of your own unique understanding and interpretation of the text. It’s not about arriving at the same ideas, but about finding your own voice in the conversation.

Creation, science, and intellectual freedom

Michael Bamberg also believes that the Adventist doctrine of a “recent six-day creation” plays a role in why young people leave the Adventist church. “If you’re going to insist you have to believe in creationism and be an Adventist, I don’t think that’s going to gain purchase among young people.”

Wareham, who identifies “somewhere between agnostic and atheist,” said that the church is insular and anti-intellectual by nature. “A lot of the positions of the church don’t stand up to reason when challenged.”

“There should be no scary ideas or things that you don’t want to watch or read about because they’re supposedly ‘bad.’ If a position is the most logically defensible one, it should stand up when challenged.”

Rules, lifestyle expectations, and social pressure

The SDA community is very cultural. They are very proud of their doctrinal beliefs and typically lead with those.

Jewelry is discouraged, sometimes makeup is too, and tattoos and piercings are often considered a salvational issue-like they teach that you’ll actually go to hell for getting piercings or tattoos.

A lot of SDA pastors don’t even wear wedding rings. They believe it’s vain or materialistic. Few SDAs seem to have an issue with wearing expensive clothing, driving an expensive car, or living in a large house though. It’s always interesting to hear where the line of judgment begins and ends for different people.

In most SDA churches I’ve attended women are encouraged to wear skirts or dresses to church rather than pants. Some SDA churches only allow the piano or organ to be played in church, while others think acoustic guitar is okay but nothing electric and definitely not drums.

Some congregations are more liberal and will have a full praise band, but they are uncommon in my experience. The way these rules are applied can vary considerably between families, congregations, and regions.

LGBTQ inclusion and conditional acceptance

Some former members point to a culture of discrimination within the Adventist church against people who identify as LGBTQ. Nicole Potgieter, who identifies as queer, described this as a significant reason why she no longer identifies as Adventist.

“I couldn’t understand how I’m exactly the same person that I was five minutes ago, but now all of a sudden I’m going to hell.”

“I have to believe in a God who’s going to love me irrespective of who I love and who I don’t love. The Adventist church doesn’t accept that.”

Ann believes that many young people leave because they are looking for the acceptance they were promised but did not experience. “I know I’ve heard a lot of pastors say things like, ‘The youth leave because the world is more attractive to them,’” Ann said.

“I don’t think that’s true at all. I think a lot of people leave because they want to find this thing that the church is selling them, which is that Jesus loves you, and Jesus cares for you, and full acceptance. Then, the church gives them conditional love. So, they go somewhere where love is going to be unconditional.”

Family conflict, grief, and loss of community

Leaving the church can affect parents, spouses, siblings, friendships, and entire family networks. Former Adventists describe hostility, anguish, awkward conversations, misrepresentation, and the fear that relatives may see them as spiritually lost.

Honestly, the last few days have been mentally tough. It’s difficult when we have dedicated our entire lives to the Seventh-day Adventist Church to be met with loss of friends, hostility, angst, and bitterness, all because we are convinced that many of the church’s beliefs don’t align with Scripture.

Why do Adventists see you as part of the Remnant Club or not? Why do my parents and so many close ‘friends’ feel deep emotions of mourning and pain when they hear that our family has left the Adventist Church?

One former member described the experience as “eerily awkward, almost a type of spiritual funeral, almost like a dying-off of the ones who used to be unique, elect, and remnant.”

These types of responses have been confusing and complicated to take. Are we no longer considered Christian? Does the Adventist framework only play well with other Adventists?

A former Adventist family was verbally misrepresented from the pulpit by one of the Elders who served under the former Head Elder at their previous Adventist church. The sermon connected leaving the church with being “shaken” away from God’s control and asked listeners whether they were saved.

The experience illustrates why leaving can feel like more than a change of denomination. It can challenge a person’s status within the family, the meaning of past relationships, and the assumption that remaining Adventist is necessary for salvation.

Leaving Adventism without leaving Christianity

Only some people who leave Adventism stop identifying as Christians. Brad Cooper considers himself a progressive Christian and attends a non-denominational church.

“My theology is a little of a bit of everything,” he said. “You can argue about the reliability of the Bible from here ‘till kingdom come, but I think [about] the story of Jesus himself and what he calls people to do.”

“There are ways you can keep your faith and keep your mind as well. It doesn’t have to be an either/or,” Cooper added.

Albertson concurs. “Just because you might not love a church or you might not love what they think is a prophet, it doesn’t mean that your whole faith has to go out the window,” she said. “I think for a lot of people, maybe it does, but that’s not how it feels for me.”

Ronald Emanuel describes his departure in explicitly Christian terms. Leaving the Seventh-day Adventist Church did not mean leaving Christ. On the contrary, it meant finally understanding the sufficiency of His grace and the finality of His work of redemption.

It meant trusting in His righteousness, not my effort. It meant letting go of fear and embracing the assurance that comes from the gospel alone, through faith alone, in Christ alone.

Other former Adventists move in different directions. Wareham identifies “somewhere between agnostic and atheist.” Some explore other Christian traditions, while others examine Jewish heritage, secular philosophy, or spirituality outside institutional religion.

Why young adults leave

In a 2011 survey of former Seventh-day Adventist Church members, 62.5 percent of respondents reported that they were young adults when they left the Adventist church.

In a 2018 survey of global church members, 58 percent of respondents in the North American Division were aged over 55, and the average age of respondents was 57.

The question of why young adults consider abandoning the belief system they were once enmeshed in has been the subject of debates, articles, sermons, and initiatives.

Wareham entered a secular university and encountered denominations and ideas outside the Adventist framework. Ann moved from Adventist schools and workplaces into public education and discovered how much of a bubble she had been raised in.

Irizarry experienced isolation after moving from a vibrant Hispanic congregation to a small rural church where she and her sister were often the only youth who regularly attended.

“It was a cultural shock for me, and it was a complete change.”

She later said that young people may become alienated when strict and insular environments leave little room for honest questions, intellectual exploration, emotional openness, or differences in identity.

Young adults who stay in the Adventist church tend to have had their own profound experiences testing their beliefs. Irizarry describes herself as a “rebel on the inside.”

“I really didn’t have a choice. I was scared of ever sharing my real thoughts to my family because at the end of the day, I knew that this would hurt them.”

Those who question but remain Adventist

Not everyone who questions Adventism leaves immediately or completely. Ann still attends Adventist churches, but she doesn’t consider herself Adventist.

“It’s a little complicated because I still attend Adventist churches, but I don’t consider myself Adventist,” she told Spectrum.

She now attends a different Adventist church-but only for the social aspect and not because she professes faith in the doctrines. She appreciates the concept of the Sabbath, and many of her friends are rooted in Adventism.

“The times that I’ve allowed myself to not go [to church] are more refreshing for me, because it helps me recenter and focus on what I actually believe and actually think about what God wants me to do outside of this organization that I already know is a bubble,” she said.

“I don’t really know how to function completely without it.”

Irizarry spent a large portion of her teenage years identifying as agnostic while continuing to play a role in her local church as a leader. “I still prayed, and I still performed all the things, but I didn’t really believe in it.”

Her perspective changed after spending a week at Camp Akita, the Adventist summer camp in Illinois, when she was 17. It was a completely new experience for her.

“It was hope and happiness and fun and God. Seeing God as like, whoa, you can worship and have fun!”

“We’re obsessed. Jesus coming was a scary thing. I might be idealistic, but I want to know that God loves me. I want to know that God is here for me. I want to have hope. I want to look into the future and feel peace. And I don’t feel peace when I’m thinking about the world just burning into ashes.”

The following summer, Irizarry was baptized at Camp Akita. Now, she works at the camp and volunteers as the Pathfinder director at her local church.

Leaving as a matter of conscience

Ronald Emanuel describes leaving as one of the most difficult spiritual decisions he has ever made. For years, he was committed to the church’s teachings, endeavored to live by the 28 Fundamental Beliefs, and fellowshipped within the community with sincerity and conviction.

“I do not write this as one embittered or hostile, nor do I desire to disparage those who remain; rather, I write as one who, after careful Bible study, prayer, and soul-searching, could no longer uphold several foundational teachings of the denomination in good conscience.”

He describes his journey as a matter of conscience held captive to the Word of God rather than a story of rebellion or personal offense.

One former Adventist argues that Christians have the vital responsibility to test teachings, doctrines, systems, religious teachers, preachers, prophets, and prophetesses with the word of God.

As we move through life, we will encounter many conflicting teachings, doctrines, systems, religious teachers, and preachers. We cannot and should not avoid the need to think freely and test every doctrine, teaching, teacher, preacher, prophet, or prophetess with the word of God.

This approach can be experienced as liberating by people who have been taught that questioning the church is dangerous or disloyal. However, it can also intensify conflict with relatives and congregations that regard Adventist teachings as essential to Christian faithfulness.

Religious anxiety and trauma after leaving

Departing from a high-control religious setting can bring fear even when the decision feels necessary. Former members may worry about hell, divine judgment, end-time events, losing salvation, disappointing parents, or no longer belonging to a chosen remnant.

Some former Adventists describe this as religious trauma. The effects can include guilt, shame, hypervigilance, difficulty trusting personal judgment, confusion about morality, and fear of making ordinary decisions without religious permission.

Learning about religious trauma and its effects can offer insights into your experiences and validate your feelings. Working with a therapist, especially one familiar with religious trauma, can be instrumental in processing your journey and developing coping strategies.

Recognize that your feelings are legitimate. Connecting with others who have undergone similar experiences can provide comfort and understanding.

Explore interests, values, and beliefs outside the framework of your former religious context to establish a sense of self that resonates with your authentic identity.

Support and community for former Adventists

Podcasts and online communities can help former Adventists hear experiences that resemble their own. Stories about deconstruction, family dynamics, purity culture, doctrinal conflict, parenting, marriage, and recovery can reduce the sense of isolation that often follows departure.

  • Haystacks & Hell: A podcast that shares stories about growing up Seventh-day Adventist, leaving the faith, and building new, fulfilling lives.
  • Former Adventist Podcast: This podcast discusses life after Adventism, exploring doctrinal issues and personal experiences of leaving the church.
  • Better Than We Thought: A podcast focusing on how understanding the gospel led the hosts to leave Adventism and find a more fulfilling spiritual life.
  • r/exAdventist on Reddit: An online community where former Adventists share experiences, offer support, and discuss their journeys.

Former Adventists may also find support through trusted friends outside the church, secular or faith-based therapists, local communities, and religious groups that allow open questions without demanding immediate agreement.

Personal identity after Adventism

Leaving can create freedom, but it can also create a temporary loss of direction. Former members may need to reconsider what they believe about God, the Bible, salvation, the Sabbath, diet, sexuality, clothing, entertainment, education, relationships, money, work, and community.

One former Adventist developed a personal relationship with God early in childhood and understood that connection as having been built within the context of the SDA church. She believed that clinging to religion early on gave her the structure and sense of purpose and value she was lacking within her family environment.

Another former Adventist later explored Jewish culture and religion to learn more about her heritage and help rectify the loss of being prevented from exploring it during childhood.

For others, identity develops through secular education, new friendships, creative work, family life, other Christian traditions, or simply the freedom to make decisions without the constant fear of violating religious rules.

Leaving the Seventh-day Adventist Church is therefore not a single type of experience. Some people leave because they no longer accept particular doctrines; some because the church’s social environment conflicts with their values; some because they feel rejected; and some because the gap between institutional teaching and lived practice becomes impossible to ignore.

noimgs

tags: #former #seventh #day #adventist